🧵 YouTube decides your niche, not you. YouTube categorizes you...
Abu (YouTube Strategist)@NotNotAbu2
19 views
Sep 01, 2025
~5 min read
Advertisement
1
🧵 YouTube decides your niche, not you.
YouTube categorizes you based on viewer behavior.
If that doesn't match the niche you originally chose, YouTube will show your video to the wrong people.
Let me explain: (thread)
YouTube categorizes you based on viewer behavior.
If that doesn't match the niche you originally chose, YouTube will show your video to the wrong people.
Let me explain: (thread)
2
YouTube is a giant pattern recognition machine.
Every video you upload sends data into the system: how many people clicked, how long they watched, how many videos they watched after, how similar those behaviors were to viewers on other channels.
When YouTube sees strong repeating patterns, e.g: when your audience reliably engages with productivity hacks but ignores your lifestyle vlogs, YouTube concludes that "this channel satisfies viewers interested in productivity, so that’s their niche”.
Once this label sticks, your future growth depends on how well you lean into that expectation.
Every video you upload sends data into the system: how many people clicked, how long they watched, how many videos they watched after, how similar those behaviors were to viewers on other channels.
When YouTube sees strong repeating patterns, e.g: when your audience reliably engages with productivity hacks but ignores your lifestyle vlogs, YouTube concludes that "this channel satisfies viewers interested in productivity, so that’s their niche”.
Once this label sticks, your future growth depends on how well you lean into that expectation.
3
So it doesn’t matter if you think of yourself as a gaming creator, finance creator, or lifestyle vlogger. If your audience only clicks when you post a very specific type of video, like a challenge-based content or budgeting hacks, that’s your real niche.
YouTube doesn’t look at your upload titles and take your word for it. It looks at audience behavior, and if 80% of your traction comes from one style or topic, that’s the identity the algorithm assigns to your channel. The more consistent that viewer response is, the better your categorization becomes.
YouTube doesn’t look at your upload titles and take your word for it. It looks at audience behavior, and if 80% of your traction comes from one style or topic, that’s the identity the algorithm assigns to your channel. The more consistent that viewer response is, the better your categorization becomes.
4
This is also why viral videos can backfire. Let’s say you usually post finance content, but you upload a lifestyle video that goes viral. Suddenly you have tens of thousands of new viewers who subscribed because of the lifestyle angle, not finance advice.
When you go back to posting finance, those new subscribers don’t click. YouTube sees a huge drop-off in interest and assumes your content is weak. The viral hit attracted the wrong audience, messed up your signals, and made it harder for the algorithm to recommend you in the future.
When you go back to posting finance, those new subscribers don’t click. YouTube sees a huge drop-off in interest and assumes your content is weak. The viral hit attracted the wrong audience, messed up your signals, and made it harder for the algorithm to recommend you in the future.
5
Creators often believe their intentions shape their channel, but YouTube doesn’t care what you intended, it cares about what viewers actually did.
That’s why you’ll sometimes see a creator who wants to be known for their deep, high-effort projects, but their audience only clicks on their quick experiments. This is very common for documentary channels who won't get any views on their "uniquely" edited videos, but will get views on the video with normal edits.
Unless you deliberately resist and reset your signals, YouTube will keep pulling you toward the content their audience already proved they like, whether or not that’s what the you wants to be known for.
That’s why you’ll sometimes see a creator who wants to be known for their deep, high-effort projects, but their audience only clicks on their quick experiments. This is very common for documentary channels who won't get any views on their "uniquely" edited videos, but will get views on the video with normal edits.
Unless you deliberately resist and reset your signals, YouTube will keep pulling you toward the content their audience already proved they like, whether or not that’s what the you wants to be known for.
6
The problem with this is if YouTube picks the niche you're not after, you will be forced to cater to that niche against your will. Otherwise the channel will just not get views and it will die.
And if you do cater to that niche even if you originally didn't want to, it won't be sustainable and you will be more prone to burn outs than your competition.
So it's a losing game for you.
And if you do cater to that niche even if you originally didn't want to, it won't be sustainable and you will be more prone to burn outs than your competition.
So it's a losing game for you.
7
The good news is that while you don’t directly control your niche, you can influence it. You do this by intentionally creating content that attracts the viewers you want long-term, and by avoiding uploads that bring in the wrong audience.
Every video will either bring you closer to your desired niche or further away. If you want to be in a certain niche, you have to upload repeatedly into that niche until both your viewers and YouTube associate your channel with it.
Every video will either bring you closer to your desired niche or further away. If you want to be in a certain niche, you have to upload repeatedly into that niche until both your viewers and YouTube associate your channel with it.
8
Here's how you can make sure YouTube doesn't mess up and assigns you the wrong niche:
9
Method 1: Reverse-engineer your target audience
Reverse-engineer your ideal niche and figure out who you want to serve, what topics they respond to, and design content specifically for them.
This may mean sacrificing some short-term growth because you're spending resources in a lot of research, but that research is important and it’s the only way to align your channel with your long-term vision. Otherwise, you’ll end up trapped in a niche you didn’t actually want.
Reverse-engineer your ideal niche and figure out who you want to serve, what topics they respond to, and design content specifically for them.
This may mean sacrificing some short-term growth because you're spending resources in a lot of research, but that research is important and it’s the only way to align your channel with your long-term vision. Otherwise, you’ll end up trapped in a niche you didn’t actually want.
10
Method 2: Resist misaligned virality
Before you chase a viral trend, ask yourself: "If this video blows up, do I want those viewers sticking around?" If the answer is no, you’re setting yourself up for failure.
Viral videos that attract misaligned audiences are one of the fastest ways to kill your channel’s momentum. Sometimes the smartest move is to pass on easy virality and sacrifice those short-term views for videos that will bring in the right long-term viewers.
Before you chase a viral trend, ask yourself: "If this video blows up, do I want those viewers sticking around?" If the answer is no, you’re setting yourself up for failure.
Viral videos that attract misaligned audiences are one of the fastest ways to kill your channel’s momentum. Sometimes the smartest move is to pass on easy virality and sacrifice those short-term views for videos that will bring in the right long-term viewers.
11
Method 3: Produce with intention
Once you know the audience you want, you need to feed them consistently. Create related uploads that guide viewers deeper into your niche. Package them in a way that makes them look connected. Train your viewers to see your channel as a focused destination.
Over time, this clarity compounds into stronger recommendations, higher CTR, and more returning viewers.
Once you know the audience you want, you need to feed them consistently. Create related uploads that guide viewers deeper into your niche. Package them in a way that makes them look connected. Train your viewers to see your channel as a focused destination.
Over time, this clarity compounds into stronger recommendations, higher CTR, and more returning viewers.
12
Method 4: Audit your competition
Look up your competitors and look at your top videos from the last 90 or 180 days. What do they have in common? Is it a specific topic, a specific format, or even a certain style of title/thumbnail?
Those patterns are your actual niche. If all your top videos share similarities, YouTube is telling you what audience it thinks you serve. Ignore this at your own risk.
Look up your competitors and look at your top videos from the last 90 or 180 days. What do they have in common? Is it a specific topic, a specific format, or even a certain style of title/thumbnail?
Those patterns are your actual niche. If all your top videos share similarities, YouTube is telling you what audience it thinks you serve. Ignore this at your own risk.
13
TL;DR: You don't pick your niche, it's defined by your viewers, and reinforced by the algorithm. Every upload either brings you closer to that niche or further away. Going viral on the wrong topic can also hurt your channel by attracting the wrong audience. So you should create with intention by choose the audience you want, design videos for them, and avoid getting clicks from audience that you don't want.
14
PS: I regularly give YouTube sauce exclusively to my newsletter. If you want more secret sauce, click here:
advancedyoutube.com
advancedyoutube.com
15
If you found this helpful:
1. Follow @NotNotAbu2
2. Like/retweet the 1st post
1. Follow @NotNotAbu2
2. Like/retweet the 1st post
