I tested 4 AI's with the same prompt. Who built it best? (Video...

“Design a personal To-Do List Tracker app with a premium, world-class UI.
Style direction:
Clean, minimal, Apple/Linear/Mercury-level polish
Typography: Inter font, regular weight, –5 letter spacing
Neutral base palette (white/black/gray) with 1 strong accent color for priority states (e.g., electric blue or lime green)
Rounded-2xl cards, soft shadows, subtle depth
Fluid micro-interactions:
– hover/press states
– smooth load transitions
– drag-and-drop for tasks
– ripple effect on buttons
Core screens/components:
Home Dashboard → task overview, progress bar, upcoming tasks
Task List View → sections for Today, Upcoming, Completed
Add Task Modal → priority selector, tags, due date
Calendar Integration → simple monthly/weekly task view
Profile/Settings → dark mode toggle, notification preferences
Rules:
Mobile-first layout, but responsive for desktop
Keep everything cohesive — no stock AI gradients or emojis
Design should feel like it came out of a top-tier UX studio”
Lot's of UI issues off the bat. Buttons and simple interactions seem broken or not optimal (colors and placement).
Main CTA is not visible unless you hover.
Core features are there except for the Task breakdown page which is broken.
Task functionalities working as expected with ability to add, mark as complete, and tag tasks.
Navigation was duplicated for some reason which makes it very difficult to navigate different pages and functionalities without getting lost.
Not mobile optimized or as intuitive as I would like.
Core functionalities such as ability to add, mark as complete, and tag tasks all included.
UI details seem outdated without much relation to the references I provided in my prompt (Linear, Apple).
However core flow details and flows are all intuitive and work great.
Best UI after one prompt.
Clear CTA and task creation flow. All tasks are displayed on the home screen intuitively.
Optimized mobile experience.
Easy to mark tasks as complete AND undo as well.
👑 Winner
Replit
- UI struggles right away.
– Buttons & interactions broken
– Main CTA hidden on hover
– Features mostly there, but Task Breakdown page = broken
Bolt
- Tasks + tagging worked smoothly
– BUT nav was duplicated = confusing
– Not mobile optimized
v0
- Solid core functionality (tasks, tags, flows)
– Outdated UI, ignored my design refs (Linear/Apple)
– Flows felt intuitive though
Lovable
- Best UI in 1 prompt
– Clear CTA & task flow
– All tasks displayed cleanly on home
– Mobile optimized
– Easy mark + undo complete
Winner: Lovable.
Closest to a shippable app in one prompt.
