One thing that I find weird is that @Brad_Setser thinks that China...

@joequant
Joequant@joequant
7 views Jul 26, 2025 ~2 min read
Advertisement
1
One thing that I find weird is that @Brad_Setser thinks that China should do massive fiscal stimulus. In fact China has very good reasons not to do fiscal stimulus.

So Chinese economic planning is based on targeting GDP. The target this year is 5 percent, and because ...
2
@Brad_Setser we run above target, they are only putting moderate amounts of stimulus. It is important to understand that the GDP is a *target* and not a *quota*. If it looked like China was running above 5 percent they would cool the economy.
3
@Brad_Setser One reason that China doesn't want to put in massive fiscal stimulus is that if there is some trade shock (i.e. Trump wakes up and wants a trade war), then China will need massive fiscal stimulus then, so they are keeping the powder dry.
4
@Brad_Setser Also simply transfering funds to local govts runs into issues. The first is that you actually don't need that much money to get rid of bottlenecks. The issue with local govts, is that a lot of them have cash problems. They can't pay workers who then don't pay taxes.
5
@Brad_Setser In turns out that to unblock these cash issues you don't need a huge amount of money. But before they write big checks, they have to figure out where the money is going, and even then it doesn't solve a lot of problems.
6
@Brad_Setser One reason local govts got into trouble to begin with is that they don't have the cash to fund their operations so they start businesses that hopefully make money. So they were making money from real estate. Now that that is gone, you have to fix the deficits.
7
@Brad_Setser This likely means some ongoing transfer payments from richer provinces to poorer ones, but that needs to be worked out.
Actions
What You Can Do
  • Export as PDF or Markdown
  • Batch Export to Notion
  • Bookmark & Highlight
  • Screenshot Tweet
Create Free Account

Includes 7-day Premium trial

Advertisement