How to trade A not-engagement bait thread 1/

@ScottPh77711570
Scott Phillips, O.G.@ScottPh77711570
15 views Apr 04, 2025 ~7 min read
Advertisement
1
How to trade

A not-engagement bait thread

1/
2
A lot of retail gurus tell you the markets are beatable

If only you have a plan and stick to it

Or carefully log all your trades

Or journal about how your mummy spanked you and it made you take off your stop loss on audjpy

This is bullshit, obviously

2/
3
You are competing against the smartest people in the world, who have the best infrastructure and are well capitalized

Your “plan” is to lose all your money and give even more money to some furu to patiently explain why you lost it

/3
4
Further, some plans are complicated by stop losses and targets (which have absolutely no influence on the market)

4/
5
Placing a stop 10 ticks away and a target 30 ticks away sounds smart but its dumb

For a bunch of reasons I cant be arsed explaining

/5
6
Id like to point you towards a *better* way and Ill even do you a solid and show you some trades, ok?

/6
7
The no bullshit version of trading is to put trades on when you have edge

And take them off when you dont

7/
8
“But Scott, what about <famous 80s guy>”? Who said to always use stops

Stop losses aren't terrible if you are trading momentum

Momentum (what I mainly trade and the real effect behind TA) used to be strong, but weakened progressively through 2010-2020 (and made a comeback)

/8
9
Some weak edges that work despite being widely known

People will pay you to take on risk

Carry trades, style premia, buy and hold

/9
10
For example I can get paid 20%/year to hold usd.e stablecoin on bybit

USD.e converts the yield from Ethereum into a stablecoin yield

And 1.3b of ETH got stolen from bybit by North Korea today

You can see how this might be problematic

/10
11
So you got paid the extra yield for taking risk

Taking risk is… risky

Today those risks came due and usd.e holders had a butthole clenching moment

All worked out in the end but it could have gone the other way

/11
12
MANY edges in finance (most of the widely known ones) have this shitty aspect to them

Buying value stocks you look like a dummy when people pile into GameStop

Carry trades are terrifying when they unwind

Trend doesn’t work when markets are sideways

Many such cases

/12
13
No pain, no premium is the general rule (h/t @choffstein)

But there is another category of BETTER edges

Most of those are kept secret since they disappear when people figure them out

/13
14
@choffstein Let’s be clear - taking on risk others don’t want is likely to be something that you get paid for

Because it’s USEFUL

AND because it sucks ass

/14
15
@choffstein Let’s look at one thats perfectly fine

There is a weekend seasonality effect that has persisted in BTC since the bitcoin ETF’s launched

You can see that on average, BTC goes down on weekends

/15
Media image
16
@choffstein This is understandable since BTC is the most liquid market to hedge out geopolitical risk when real markets are closed.

When we design a trade to take advantage of this we DON’T want to backtest some complicated Rube Goldberg machine of stop losses and targets

/16
17
@choffstein You want to reach for the simplest tool in your box

Here you would obviously sell BTC on Friday and buy back Monday morning

Put your trade on when you have edge and pull it off when you don’t innit?

/17
18
@choffstein Some MORE trades you might want to consider (in crypto, because trades are easier to find in crypto)

Basis trades - long <SCAMCOIN> spot, short <SCAMCOIN> futures is a good trade

Why?

/18
19
@choffstein Well, you are taking a bunch of hidden risks.

Counterparty/hacking/smart contract risk

Risk that the carry disappears

Operational risk (a successful long grows and short shrinks)

These all suck

/19
20
@choffstein It makes sense that someone wouldn’t want to go through all that bullshit just to earn 20% so that’s WHY the trade exists

/20
21
Another trade you might consider is shorting new listings on major exchanges (since those are mostly crime)

On average, these new listings just enable some insider cashing in and selling, so they are a good trade

But every now and again you are gonna get a TRUMP

So it sucks

/21
22
@choffstein Another trade you might consider is if you think carry trades are paying TOO much you can take that trade with pendle.finance which lets you bet on that shit

/22
23
@choffstein Let’s look at some more advanced, and more profitable trades

They all require someone to be trading at bad prices and you to be trading at good prices

/23
24
@choffstein At this point you run headfirst into your first and primary problem as a retail trader.

“There is no beginners market” @therobotjames

Which sucks. It really does

/24
25
What are “bad prices”?

Bad prices are caused by price insensitive flows

Like liquidated traders

Like people who don’t care what the terms are they just want to back Dave Portnoy’s memecoin cos they like him and trust him

Like market makers who are too slow

These are great

/25
26
@choffstein @therobotjames But great opportunities attract sharks, and sadly, most of them are really smart, well capitalized and experienced

You ought to think very carefully about getting involved with trades like this

/25
27
@choffstein @therobotjames If you *think* you have edge on NQ or EURUSD because “you’ve got some TA to back it up” you are fucking stupid and you need to stop being stupid before you have any chance of making money

/26
28
@choffstein @therobotjames Your best chance of finding edge ISN’T in the most liquid markets, it’s 4th tier shitcoin casinos, weak sportsbooks, polymarket stuff

This is important. Arguably the most important thing (like in poker) is table selection

/27
29
Where should you look?

In stonks it is very easy to find edge on the short side of micro cap stocks

But that is because it’s operationally complicated to trade micro caps short

The same thing exists in crypto

/28
30
“Oh but I don’t wanna be a crypto trader” i style myself a man of finance.

I get it bro. You want to be respectable. I did too.

You won’t find much edge in large cap stocks or liquid futures

You just won’t

/29
31
I remember a conversation between @AgustinLebron3, @therobotjames and @SinclairEuan in our group

The question was “if you had to start again, what market would you choose?”

/30
32
Euan - finds the sketchiest Indian res casino and counts cards on blackjack (which he can do)

James - Best on women’s hockey

Agustin - Buys EOD data for some 4th tier stock exchange like Turkey or Nigeria and finds edge there

See how they are looking in places others aren’t?

/31
33
@AgustinLebron3 @therobotjames @SinclairEuan IMO the best places to look for edge

1. Anything new (like Jane Street did with Indian ODTE), like people did with memecoins

2. Anything where it’s hard to trade, like the Korea premium in crypto. Like the short side of memecoins, like 4th tier shitcoin casinos

/33
34
I hope you can see that the standard retail playbook

1. Do technical analysis on a single chart
2. Take a bet with a stop loss (which costs you a lot of edge, because you can’t separate risk from return easily)

Is doomed to fail. But it probably used to work ok 20 yrs ago

/34
35
You know the endless parade of retail guru grifters who used to have a job in finance.

Virtually all the substack bros, actually

Mostly, they are unemployable in finance, because they don’t have edge

Because the stupid bullshit they tell you to do doesn’t work anymore

/35
36
This is a very easily testable proposition

“If you could get a job paying 1m+/year, why don’t you?”

If you believe “I’ve made enough money its my chance to give back” then you need to wash your brain out with soap

/36
37
Here’s the truth.

Gambling (that’s what trading is) is hard

You shouldn’t do it unless you have edge

/fin
Actions
What You Can Do
  • Export as PDF or Markdown
  • Batch Export to Notion
  • Bookmark & Highlight
  • Screenshot Tweet
Create Free Account

Includes 7-day Premium trial

Advertisement