Okay, good Sunday morning topic, let's talk about this. In the wake...

@bennpeifert
Benn Eifert 🥷🏴‍☠️@bennpeifert
23 views Jan 12, 2025 ~2 min read
Advertisement
1
Okay, good Sunday morning topic, let's talk about this.

In the wake of the 2008 credit crisis and Dodd-Frank there was a huge exodus of bank prop traders starting their own hedge funds. Some firms providing seed capital had this as an explicit investment thesis.
@Deathswap1
Deathswap@Deathswap1
@dahu7744 @bennpeifert That's because being a star trader/PM and starting/running an HF (aka an entrepreneur/business manager) require very different skill sets.
2
The idea was, new regulations were forcing talented traders to move out of banks, and investors could take advantage of this opportunity to have those traders manage capital for them instead of for bank shareholders.
3
There are some hedge funds set up by ex prop traders that succeeded and became well known, but the success rate was astoundingly low in practice
4
Bank prop traders have a very specific skillset:
1) make money
2) keep their boss happy (see 1)
3) run over internal risk managers (see 1 and 2)
5
A typical senior bank prop trader was confident, arrogant, sharp elbowed, at least a little narcissistic.

(Full disclosure, I was a quant / junior pm on a prop desk a long time ago, draw what conclusions you want)
6
Things bank prop traders don't have to do:
- explain what they do to asset owners
- manage people who are not their junior traders
- oversee building/implementation of trading, risk and middle office systems
- negotiate prime brokerage agreements, financing, stock borrow, ISDAs
7
- set up portfolio risk management frameworks in a way that is transparent to investors and robust to their due diligence processes
- oversee trade, position and cash reconciliation
- set up HR and payroll
- set up cybersecurity and IT systems
8
- work with lawyers to create legal entities for management companies and funds
- work with lawyers to prepare compliance manuals and enforce compliance programs internally
- set up complicated business insurance policies
- scope out commercial real estate, build out offices
9
- set up CRM systems and manage marketing processes
- write quarterly investor letters
- produce substantive content for marketing and investor relations
- attend Cayman board meetings for all your offshoe funds
10
Many of these things are quite hard and require specialized skills. Some of them can be hired for -- e.g. the very first thing you need is a COO/CFO/CCO who is incredibly experienced and detail oriented and can do the work. Others you have to be heavily involved yourself.
11
This is one of the reasons the big multi-manager platforms have done so well and absorbed so much of the hedge fund and ex prop trading industry. They take care of the vast majority of this stuff and allow portfolio managers to sit down, build their front office tools and trade.
12
I run my own firm, it's absolutely possible to do, but it takes a lot of hard work, hiring the right people, and taking a very long term perspective. And from a pure economic perspective its probably suboptimal in the vast majority of cases.
Actions
What You Can Do
  • Export as PDF or Markdown
  • Batch Export to Notion
  • Bookmark & Highlight
  • Screenshot Tweet
Create Free Account

Includes 7-day Premium trial

Advertisement