The fantasy genre by-and-large took the wrong takeaway from...

@Hieraaetus
Tristan S. Rapp@Hieraaetus
12 views Aug 23, 2025 ~1 min read
Advertisement
1
The fantasy genre by-and-large took the wrong takeaway from Tolkien, and has been generally spiraling since as a result. They took his surface-level aesthetics and fantastical elements, and left his engagement with real, historical texts, his philology & his moral seriosity.
x.com/The_Elmerian/s…
2
In a different timeline, subsequent authors would have adopted Tolkien's erudite love of language and mythology and applied it to other cultures & mythologies - not just superficially, but by engaging with the great Chinese novels or the Shahnameh like he did with Beowulf.
Media image
Media image
Media image
Media image
3
Even when you *do* see more recent novels "inspired by" other cultures, they are very blatantly just taking the (degraded distillate of the) Western, Tolkien-esque tradition and coating it in a thin veneer of Chinese or Mesoamerican lore.
4
They are not applying Tolkien's approach of deep engagement in the textual tradition to a new culture, but are instead just going "what if we took Tolkien-through-D&D fantasy, made all the names Japanese, added some Wikipedia-tier local lore, and made it YA?"

Unimpressed.
Media image
5
Most fantasy since Tolkien is not quantitatively but qualitatively inferior, like comparing Dan Brown to Dickens or Steinbeck.
Actions
What You Can Do
  • Export as PDF or Markdown
  • Batch Export to Notion
  • Bookmark & Highlight
  • Screenshot Tweet
Create Free Account

Includes 7-day Premium trial

Advertisement