Let's talk about under ice operations of AIP (Air Independent...

@DivebumChef
Christopher E Richardson@DivebumChef
15 views Aug 29, 2025 ~5 min read
Advertisement
1
Let's talk about under ice operations of AIP (Air Independent Propulsion) submarines.

Because, it's amazing how many folks are honestly wrong about the viability.

LONG thread🧵
Media image
2
While I was once a submariner, my views on AIP under ice is more formed by doing LOTS of diving in an overhead environment, teaching it (and others to teach it) as well as being a test pilot for new tech in that environment more often than may be sane
Media image
3
One thing often said is that for under ice ops, the subs ability to surface for an emergency is critical. That's BS. The reality is that no matter what type of sub in an emergency under thick ice the surface is not going to be an option. In thin ice it's at best a "maybe"
Media image
4
How thick the ice is is only part of the equation anyhow, as brine content, temp, compression of ice (aka what type of ice) also makes a huge difference.
Oh, check out who is studying this..

Russian prof in China..
mdpi.com/2077-1312/11/4…
5
But, while surfacing thru ice in an emergency may be a procedure to think it is going to be a REQUIRED option is silly.

Just like NOBODY thinks a submarine compartment escape is going to be an option, but we train for it. Most sub ops are in simply too deep water
Media image
6
So, submarines operating where some emergency procedures simply won't work is VERY normal. WE just don't talk about much because peace of mind and loved ones ashore want to feel better.
Media image
7
That all said, the part of me that designs dive gear and the submariner part of me agree on something that I have never seen discussed/done that I do believe would be one hella good thing to have regards emergency ventilation for under ice ops.. so CDN sub folks feel free to ask.
Media image
8
So, how should under ice ops be done by AIP subs? Umm, not unlike nuke boats really. Just endurance is less, but still not by as much as most think. It's not the powerplant, it's food.

Oh, I was a sub cook, so also something I know about.
Media image
9
An AIP boat will have more than enough for the limits of it dived endurance, and we are seeing in the CDN sub request they are saying 21 days min, most modern AIP boats are pushing 30 according to open source rumours. It is classified for reasons
Media image
10
Nuke boats, the attack type not the massive SSBN types, aren't gonna have food storage that is significantly longer than a modern medium to large AIP boat like Canada will be looking at.

That is all I am saying on that lest I piss off folks.
11
Anyhow, let's go with what gov of Canada has said they want.

dropbox.com/scl/fi/yivk4h3…
Media image
12
Interesting enough, that throws cold water on something the navy thinks they will need, namely an Arctic base for 4 boats

canadiandefencereview.com/dnd-releases-r…
Media image
13
BUT.. the RFI shows the boats will have LOTS of range, like a serious amount, and endurance generally. More than enough to operate in the Arctic and under ice AND the BIG salty lake to the left side of Canada . The RFI use of "(2x3500nm) is significant.
Media image
14
Back to the overhead environment, under ice.

You have to have endurance, and confidence in that endurance. AIP that is getting closer to a month than week is derivative improvement technology. Not new but still in the "get full confidence in" stage twz.com/news-features/….
15
Note that boat is small, smaller than ours will likely be. We will have longer endurance.

So, once confidence in our new boats is high, under ice ops will commence, progressively getting further and longer. Building confidence under the ice and expanding risk tolerance
Media image
16
A note on risk tolerance and submarine operations in general let alone under ice, it TRULY is risk tolerance and acceptance, not risk aversion or avoidance. It's can be extremely safe when everything goes well, but once it starts going wrong the odds suck.

Top right of this.
Media image
17
The drivers of these subs will be testing the boats, crew and themselves in the risk tolerance area. There will be levels of, for normal patrols, transits, real operational limits (that in fact may/should be less than normal peace patrols in some cases) and the "gone to hell"
Media image
18
Much of it is actually simple math. Time, distance, supplies, reserve capacity for emergencies based on risk profile and tolerance.
Media image
19
That "math" will be done with the coldness of a ford pinto actuary with the only difference being the actuary is driving it, and still cold as hell.

Because..well have you met submariners, let alone our skippers?
Media image
20
Now, let's talk speed. Many think we need it.

Sigh..
Media image
21
Read this, does that really plant a image of speed when you do? It sure should not

usni.org/magazines/proc….
Media image
22
Speed is good for fast transits in uncontested waters or escorting really fast somethings. The first is a "gone" in a peer war with those we are likely to face in Arctic, Russia and China. Even transits will have to be slow and stealth.
Media image
23
Oh, and a Canadian sub isn't gonna be escorting anything fast in Arctic, because nothing can go fast there.. just saying.

Fast SSN's escort fast CV groups.. not our wheelhouse and they won't be icebreaking..
Media image
24
In combat for a submarine, speed is noise and it kills subs. There are VERY few times where speed will help, very, very, very few

In fact, that even "professional" surface warfare officers often think post attack we try for a quick exit is...well funny. We slow down most times
Media image
25
I hope this helped, because "IF" we do get 8-12 modern AIP boats, we WILL own the Canadian Arctic by the simple nature of having a more stealthy platform than nuke boats, operating in an environment that further negates a SSN advantages and control of vital choke points
Media image
Actions
What You Can Do
  • Export as PDF or Markdown
  • Batch Export to Notion
  • Bookmark & Highlight
  • Screenshot Tweet
Create Free Account

Includes 7-day Premium trial

Advertisement