A month ago I made the case that an underground 5+ kT 3rd-...

@drbairdonline
Bruce Baird@drbairdonline
19 views Jan 03, 2025 ~24 min read
Advertisement
1
A month ago I made the case that an underground 5+ kT 3rd-generation nuke was responsible for the 2020 Beirut blast. Could an array of several such 3rd-generation nukes have been responsible for the utter destruction of the WTC on 9/11?
Thread
1/

@drbairdonline
Bruce Baird@drbairdonline
The kind of person who believes 2750 tonnes of ammonium nitrate stacked in bags on a warehouse floor blasted a 43-meter deep crater in Beirut is the kind of person who believes two jetliners caused the Twin Towers to "collapse" & destroyed the rest of WTC on 9/11!
Thread
1/
Media image
Media image
2
Besides 2020 Beirut, I’ve also made the case recently that 3rd-generation Minimum Residual Radiation SADMs w/yield 10-20 kT TNT equiv were used in 1983 US Marine barracks bombing, four mega-blasts in 1990s England & 2005 Beirut blast that killed former Lebanese PM Rafiq Hariri
2/
Media image
Media image
Media image
3
This thread picks up from where I left off in another long thread examining where the immense energy needed to destroy the WTC on 9/11 & maintain hot spots in the ground for 99 days could have come from
3/

@drbairdonline
Bruce Baird@drbairdonline
WHERE could the immense ENERGY needed to destroy the WTC on 9/11 AND maintain hot spots in the ground for 99 days have come from? Many observers have judged NO WAY could gravity & ANY chemical source (e.g., nanothermite) have provided sufficient ENERGY. So WHERE?
Thread
1/
Media image
Media image
4
Physicist Heinz Pommer in Apr 2017 presentation to London 9/11Keeptalking group, based on multiple criteria, certainly thought 3rd-generation nuclear weapons (Directed Energy/Minimum Residual Radiation) were "the prime suspect for being used on 9/11."
4/

@drbairdonline
Bruce Baird@drbairdonline
On almost all criteria, Pommer concluded that 3rd-generation nuclear weapons (Directed Energy/Minimum Residual Radiation weapons) developed by the US in the 1970s were "the prime suspect for being used on 9/11."
109/
Media image
Media image
Media image
Media image
5
Yet, as promising as Pommer had made the case for 3rd-generation nukes seem, only a year later he completely abandoned the idea when he gave a follow-up presentation to the same London 9/11Keeptalking group (1 May 2018) in pursuit of some mysterious 0th-generation nuke!
5/
Media image
Media image
Media image
Media image
6
So what are 3rd-generation nuclear weapons and what is it about them that makes someone as measured in his conclusions as physicist Heinz Pommer totally accept them as "the prime suspect for being used on 9/11" and then absolutely reject them the following year?
6/
Media image
7
The idea of a "3rd-gen nuke" goes back to the late 1950s in arguments in support of developing the "neutron bomb". US scientists then were working on "clean" weapons that produced little or no radioactive fallout by minimizing % energy from fission & maxing % from fusion
7/
Media image
8
Congress & Ike liked LLNL idea of "neutron bomb" as tactical weapon w/fusion energy tailored to produce burst of neutrons like "a kind of death ray, doing almost no physical damage & leaving no contamination, but immediately destroying all life in the target area"
8/
Media image
9
Dec 1959 Thomas E Murray, former AEC member, told reporters the atomic test ban in effect at that time, was hurting US. Tests had helped develop A-bomb & H-bomb, "It the third generation of these weapons is the neutron bomb, it can't be proven until it, too, is tested."
9/
Media image
Media image
Media image
10
In late 1950s, US had quite an array of “small” 1st-gen tactical nukes for use as atomic demolition munitions (ADMs), artillery shells & warheads. E.g, W-25 warhead (left) weighed only 218 lbs & W-30 warhead (right) had yield as low as 300 tons TNT
10/
nuclearweaponarchive.org/Usa/Weapons/Al…
Media image
Media image
11
But, as noted by Andre Gsponer, “the major disadvantage of 1st-generation nuclear weapons is that they produce effects whose combination is never optimal from the military perspective” making them good for “strategic deterrence” but not for “limited nuclear war fighting”
11/
Media image
Media image
Media image
Media image
12
But the “neutron bomb” would be designed to MINIMIZE mechanical, thermal & electromagnetic effects & MAXIMIZE radiological effects, while localizing radioactive fallout. It’s this ability to tailor effects that would define the "neutron bomb" as the first 3rd-generation nuke
12/
Media image
Media image
Media image
13
The "enhanced radiation weapon" (official DOD name for the "neutron bomb") successfully tested in 1963 but Kennedy & Johnson admins resisted developing any "cleaner" nuke for fear they would be "considered more usable if war broke out" & lead to WWIII
13/
isri.ch/wiki/_media/pu…
Media image
Media image
14
But with reduced strategic deterrence due to SALT, reduced conventional forces in Europe & W German refusal to permit "dirty" large tactical nukes on their soil, the Nixon admin began to favor idea of "cleaner" smaller nukes
14/
books.google.com/books?id=ajswh…
Media image
Media image
15
Little did any of this "calm" discussion of "neutron bomb" anticipate the furor over the spin that a bomb had been designed to kill people but preserve bldgs when the WaPo reported that funds to start building it had been buried in 1977 ERDA budget.
15/
washingtonpost.com/archive/politi…
Media image
Media image
Media image
16
With all the furor over an "enhanced radiation weapon," it's interesting there was NO public controversy over a parallel DOD effort to develop the neutron bomb's 3rd-generation counterpart - a "suppressed radiation weapon" - i.e., a nuclear "blast bomb" w/o the radiation
16/
Media image
Media image
Media image
Media image
17
From beginning of Cold War, US had been looking for ways to reduce radioactive fallout. In 1967, AEC even announced work on "pure fusion weapons - that is, hydrogen bombs & missiles that would not require an A-bomb trigger and would therefore be free of radioactive fallout."
17/
Media image
Media image
Media image
Media image
18
While AEC working on 4th-generation fissionless fusion weapons, Lawrence Livermore (LLNL) was quite active trying to find more immediate & practical ways to reduce radioactive fallout as part of Project Plowshare's efforts to promote the idea of "peaceful nuclear explosions"
18/
Media image
Media image
Media image
Media image
19
Nuclear scientists designing a "suppressed radiation weapon" faced same kind of challenges they had overcome w/"neutron bomb". Although by 1970 LLNL had not achieved the goal of no radioactivity, they had made or suggested modifications to minimize it.
19/
inis.iaea.org/collection/NCL…
Media image
Media image
20
Early 1970s Nixon administration "without fuss or fanfare" was channeling $10-20 million a year "into research and development on a variety of smaller, 'cleaner' weapons, including suppressed radiation weapons"
20/
Media image
Media image
21
1976 US Dept of Energy (DOE) launched three-year program to produce a "Reduced Residual Radioactivity (RRR) Tactical Bomb" "if you like, a very clean bomb" that was going to involve some nuclear testing.
21/
Media image
22
In 1978 DOE budget hearings, Sen McIntyre ask Gen Bratton abt "several technologies designed to tailor nuclear output such as neutron, X-ray, gamma radiation, and blast & shock effects" suggesting DOE working on many more types of 3rd-gen nukes than "neutron bomb" & RRR bomb
22/
Media image
23
Re "tailored effect," Gen Bratton, DOE Director of Military Applications, only wanted to talk abt enhanced radiation weapon & RRR ("achieving a weapon" w/less radiation contamination of area so friendly units could enter more quickly & limited collateral damage to civilians
23/
Media image
24
1978 NYTimes reported US scientists had started work on RRR bomb aka "blast bomb" to be "detonated at ground level", "tactical mission...to dig huge craters, demolish buildings or bury mtn passes under debris” but "minimize residual radiation"
24/
nytimes.com/1978/05/01/arc…
25
WaPo reported "a blast bomb...is planned to explode ON or UNDER the ground, throwing enormous amounts of debris" & quoted govt nuclear weapons expert "This is the original idea of a 'clean bomb'...designed to create a minimum amt of fallout"
25/
washingtonpost.com/archive/politi…
26
AP 5/78 Am nuclear scientists "still years away fm producing a “clean” tactical nuclear bomb but...have gone a long way toward mastering the key process wch would result in total combustion of nuclear materials in an explosion", only “prompt radiation” wch disappears quickly
26/
Media image
Media image
27
"Highlights of Laboratory achievements during 1979" reported “A three-year LLNL development pgm has culminated in a new kind of tactical nuclear explosive [RRR]" w/fallout & rainout fm surface burst more than order of magnitude less than all-fission explosive of same yld
27/
Media image
Media image
Media image
28
As significant as that LLNL achievement was in producing the RRR, what is even more amazing is that (apart from this passing mention in NYTimes - in 1985!) #MSM never reported the achievement
28/
nytimes.com/1985/07/16/sci…
Media image
Media image
29
Indeed, during the whole debate over Reagan's SDI (or later) when so many reporters were writing abt 3rd-generation nuclear weapons, nobody in MSM mentioned RRR (again w/exception of brief NYTimes ref) or MRR (Minimum Residual Radiation - name adopted by DOE at some point).
29/
Media image
Media image
30
As to what actually happened to the RRR tactical nuke, that's still classified. But we get occasional clues like in 2003 Kathleen Bailey & Robert Barker recommended "reduced residual radiation warheads for low collateral damage" for Bush's Advanced Concepts Initiative (ACI)
30/
Media image
Media image
31
Physicist Peter Zimmerman, SFRC consultant, replied: "RRR weapons would be similar to the 'neutron' bombs, made in the 1970s, w/very low fission yld. For classified reasons they cannot be readily made today w/o compromise to higher priority programs."
31/
everycrsreport.com/files/20040308…
Media image
32
Although RRRs were forgotten, 1980s MSM was filled with stories of a "new generation" of young nuclear scientists - for whom the "neutron bomb" was only a "crude forerunner" - inventing all kinds of 3rd-generation nuclear devices
32/
nytimes.com/1984/01/31/sci…
Media image
Media image
33
This optimism wasn't restricted to young scientists. Physicist Ted Taylor who had been at the center of a lot of the developments at Los Alamos in the early 50s, told journalist John McPhee in 1972 "If you want a bomb that spews out nothing but green paint, you can do that.”
33/
Media image
Media image
Media image
34
Reagan admin officials in 1982 cited examples of contemplated weapons:
1) bombs to create large EMP to knock out enemy communications systems
2) nuke-powered X-ray lasers to destroy enemy missiles
3) DEWs tailored to destroy target w/few side effects
34/
nytimes.com/1982/10/29/us/…
Media image
35
1985 NYTimes most thorough review of 3rd-gen nukes (the one article that mentioned RRRs!) including DEWs; X-ray & gamma-ray lasers; EMP, antimatter & brain bombs; microwave & particle beam weapons. DOE now testing X-ray lasers & other 3rd-gen weapons.
35/
nytimes.com/1985/07/16/sci…
Media image
Media image
Media image
Media image
36
1986 LLNL physicists say dozens, maybe hundreds, varieties of "nuclear-powered directed-energy weapons, or NDEWS" could be developed in wch some type of energy produced in every nuclear explosion (e.g, X-rays) is stepped up & focused on distant target
36/
washingtonpost.com/archive/politi…
Media image
37
May 1987 Time article revealed details of work on X-ray lasers (codenamed "Excalibur"), "a kind of nuclear shotgun with little pellets" ("Prometheus"), microwave weapons & NDEWs but says debate NOT whether CAN BE developed but whether SHOULD BE
37/
content.time.com/time/magazine/…
38
Congress started scaling back funding for NDEWs in research in 1989 & rhetoric also cooled, but research and underground nuclear tests on a number of these concepts continuing w/research shielded from Cong oversight b/c within the labs' core program
38/
books.google.com/books?id=rwwAA…
Media image
39
It is unclear what happened to any of these 3rd-gen nuke projects. Andre Gsponer wrote in 2008 most 3rd-gen weapons "never deployed on a large scale for a number of technical & political reasons" esp b/c required fission trigger so yield too high for battlefield, fallout, etc
39/
Media image
Media image
Media image
40
All Carey Sublette has to say "in passing" at his detailed "The Nuclear Weapon Archive" website is 3rd-gen nukes (e.g., X-ray laser, neutron bomb) "were never procured in large numbers, and have been largely abandoned as of little military interest."
40/
nuclearweaponarchive.org/News/INESAPTR1…
Media image
41
2008 article reports bomb-driven X-ray laser tested 1985 showed beam less bright than thought & efforts to focus the beam failed so SDI turned to other options although underground tests continued until test program stopped in 1992
41/
osa-opn.org/home/articles/…
Media image
Media image
42
But to so easily dismiss 3rd-gen nukes is to miss completely the very significant technological achievements of the “neutron bomb” & especially the reduced residual radiation (RRR) weapon whose achievements were either ignored or distorted by both MSM & nuclear scientists
42/
Media image
Media image
43
One might understand MSM not picking up on LLNL report but even William Broad’s Star Warriors (1985) that was focused on LLNL's work on 3rd-gen weapons esp X-ray laser makes NO mention of LLNL’s successful RRR weapon project completed only a few years earlier!
43/
Media image
44
Ted Taylor in his 1987 SciAm article writes residual radiation can “be controlled over very wide ranges” but adds “particulary for thermonuclear weapons with yields greater than a few hundred kilotons” ignoring fact 3rd-gen RRR weapon w/MUCH smaller yield already exists!
44/
Media image
Media image
45
Altho we don't have exact details abt RRR weapons, based on what was told Congress & media (i.e., "blast bombs" detonated on or under the ground "to dig huge craters, demolish buildings or bury mtn passes") that they were designed as "clean" Atomic Demolition Munitions (ADM).
45/
Media image
46
The US arsenal had two types of ADMs: Special ADMs (SADMs) and Medium ADMs (MADMs). The smaller SADMs used the Mk-54 warhead package w/variable yields (10 T–1 kT) weighed 59 lbs (Mk-54 only) or 150 lbs (complete) and were 16 in diameter by 24 in long.
46/
Media image
Media image
Media image
Media image
47
MADMs used W-45 warhead w/variable yields (1 kT-15kT) weighed 150 lbs (W-45 only) or 350 lbs (complete), 11.5 in diameter & 27 in long. MADMs (top left) thus had a potential blast yield (15 kT) as powerful as the Little Boy bomb that destroyed Hiroshima (all other photos)!
47/
Media image
Media image
Media image
Media image
48
In 1978 when RRR weapon being developed at LNLL, ADMs were in the news b/c W Germany didn't like that US "Zebra Package" had 141 ADMS ready to go in prepared shafts in Fulda Gap & Kinzigtal to stop the enemy at bottlenecks (bridges, highways, tunnels) if Warsaw Pact invaded
48/
Media image
49
Despite criticisms, US Army said both SADMs & MADMs needed. But some officers complained “ADMs are supposed to be exploded in deep holes to dig the biggest possible crater & to minimize radioactive fallout.” They wanted an anti-personnel radiation weapon (aka "neutron bomb")!
49/
Media image
Media image
Media image
50
In 1984 ADMs were still in the news. Jack Anderson reported “As of early 1983, according to a secret Pentagon report, the US had a total of 608 ADMs – 372 in Europe (mostly in W Germany), 21 in the Pacific (mostly in S Korea) and the rest stored in this country.”
50/
Media image
51
Anderson: "Designed to be buried underground, the ADMs’ three chief effects are cratering, blast & ground shock." Qtes Army manual “Cratering is used to destroy massive targets, such as large bridges & dams, and to create obstacles by excavating a great volume of material"
51/
Media image
52
Jack Anderson reported "Because friendly troops would be operating in the area of ADM demolition, the weapons are designed to as “clean” as possible, giving off minimal but still deadly radiation."
52/
Media image
53
Anderson 1984 reported "the ADM will be phased out over the next few years as Pershing & cruise missiles take over a larger responsibility for NATO’s defense. ADMs will remain in S Korea, however. Some have already been deployed underground near – & possibly under – the DMZ."
53/
Media image
54
Apr 1985 a curious report that, even tho NATO had agreed to remove all ADMs from Europe, DOD was developing a "nuclear backpack" nicknamed ADAM, standing for Advanced Atomic Mine. Since ADAM would do everything SADM already did, it's a good guess that ADAM really an RRR SADM!
54/
Media image
Media image
55
There was obviously a LOT of DOD interest in a "clean" SADM in 1970s & 1980s and the RRR weapon fit that bill. Indeed when GIPRI physicist Andre Gsponer first wrote about RRR in 1982, he practically described it as the ideal battlefield weapon.
55/
Media image
Media image
56
Yet in 2008 how Gsponer would change his tune saying RRR bomb & other 3rd-gen weapons "require a fission-explosive as trigger, which implies that their yield tends to be too high for battle-field uses, and that they necessarily produce large-scale radioactive pollution, etc."
56/
Media image
57
In 2009 Gsponer added RRR bomb & other 3rd-gen weapons "never found any truly convincing military use. Moreover, none of them has provided any decisive advantage (such as significantly reduced collateral damage, absence of radioactivity, etc.)"
57/
Media image
Media image
58
US not the only nuclear state interested in 3rd-gen nuclear technology. USSR 1978 successfully tested the neutron bomb, France 1980 & China 1988.
58/
web.archive.org/web/2015020708…
web.archive.org/web/2011111005…
Media image
Media image
59
28 Sep 1986 Sunday Mirror reported as possible disinfo the claim from a "junior nuclear technician" - later identified as Mordechai Vanunu - that Israel has built neutron bombs, a claim Vanunu has reaffirmed in numerous interviews over the years
59/
Media image
Media image
Media image
Media image
60
Theodore Hersh in The Samson Option (1991) reaffirmed Vanunu, based on Vanunu's photos LLNL & LANL concluded "Israel was capable of manufacturing one of the most sophisticated weapons in the nuclear arsenal—a low-yield neutron bomb". By mid-1980s Israel had produced hundreds.
60/
Media image
Media image
Media image
Media image
61
Reed & Stillman's The Nuclear Express (2010) actually concluded that Israel was the THIRD nuclear state (after US & USSR) to successfully test a neutron bomb in the infamous nuclear incident off the coast of South Africa on 22 Sep 1979
61/
Media image
Media image
Media image
62
R&S reported in wake of 1973 Yom Kippur attack Israeli govt decided they needed a neutron bomb as a tactical nuke, eventually led to 1979 test that went off as planned yielding 1-2 kt. Vanunu's 1986 revelations show
Israel’s neutron bomb in full production by 1984
62/
Media image
Media image
Media image
Media image
63
Mar 2000 Sunday Times reported on secret Israeli military plan called "David's Sling" in wch neutron bombs would by deployed as landmines near Golan Heights to thwart any tank advance, an idea that goes back to the 1980s
63/
wilsonweb.physics.harvard.edu/HUMANRIGHTS/PA…
Media image
Media image
64
Military sources say Israeli scientists have perfected a tactical neutron bomb yield 250 tonnes, weighing under 100 kg that can be carried by two soldiers. In addition, Israel has tested neutron artillery shell & laser-guided rockets with neutron warheads are ready for use.
64/
Media image
Media image
65
So did any of these nuclear states that had developed a "neutron bomb" copy the US & proceed to develop a "reduced residual radiation" (RRR) weapon - a nuke that with minimal residual radiation APPEARS much like a non-nuclear blast bomb?
65/
Media image
66
With a lot more info available on the ENHANCED radiation design, there have been a few attempts to sketch how the neutron bomb worked. The best guess is that it is a miniaturized version of the well-known Teller-Ulam design.
67/
nuclearweaponarchive.org/Nwfaq/Nfaq4-3.…
Media image
Media image
Media image
67
Pommer has found quite useful this schematic diagram (left) of a neutron bomb on the German (but NOT English) Wikipedia page on "Nuclear weapons technology" (Kernwaffentechnik). It shares a lot in common with Carey Sublette's version (right).
68/
de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kernwaffe…
Media image
Media image
68
Pommer believes RRR weapon was variation of "neutron bomb". Both required tiny fission spark & D/T fusion but RRR required neutron reflector [Be-9] & neutron absorber [B-10] to produce hard X-rays by neutron scattering/capture & minimize neutron radiation/activation fallout.
69/
Media image
69
So we can presume ALL the nuclear states who developed the "neutron bomb" - US, USSR, Israel, France, China -were fully capable of developing a 3rd-generation RRR weapon & furthermore that they all did if just to keep up w/US or see if they could replicate US results.
70/
Media image
70
I should acknowledge that in 2002 Aussie online investigator Joe Vialls reported that in 1981 Israeli scientists at Dimona had successfully developed & tested a lighter & "cleaner" SADM (that he believed Israel had used in "stealth" mode in Bali 2002)
71/
web.archive.org/web/2003021022…
Media image
Media image
71
However, Vialls' explanation that the 99.79% Plutonium-239 core of this "new" Dimona micro-nuke ONLY emitted alpha radiation & was thus undetectable by Geiger counter is WRONG. Pu-239 fission has a well-defined isotopic signature & is readily detectable by Geiger counter.
72/
Media image
Media image
72
However dubious Vialls' description of 2002 Bali bomb as 1st-gen plutonium fission bomb, his info that Dimona had successfully developed & tested a "stealth" SADM in 1981 - along lines of 3rd-gen RRR SADM that LLNL had developed by 1979 - may actually be close to the truth!
73/
Media image
Media image
73
Indeed my earlier analysis concluded that by 1983 Israel did indeed have this kind of 3rd-generation "Reduced Residual Radiation" (RRR) SADM because in that year Israeli PM Menachem Begin authorized its use to blow up the US Marine barracks in Beirut.
74/

@drbairdonline
Bruce Baird@drbairdonline
My analysis in this long thread concludes Israeli PM Menachem Begin had the "means, motive & opportunity" to authorize using a shallowly buried 10-ton "clean" NUKE to blow up the US Marine barracks in Beirut on 23 Oct 1983 killing 241 US military personnel
x.com/drbairdonline/…
Media image
Media image
74
From Aug 1970 Sterling Hall bombing thru Aug 2020 Beirut blast, the world has seen dozens of #megablasts TOO BIG to have been caused by chemical explosives yet apparently leaving no detectable radioactive fallout - thus ruling out nukes in the popular understanding of nukes
75/
Media image
Media image
Media image
75
Yet with an understanding of 3rd-gen nukes, we might suspect that quite a few of these megablasts (like 1983 Beirut) were actually the results of "nuclear state terrorism" employing RRRs in order to give plausible deniability to nuclear accusations.
76/
Media image
Media image
Media image
Media image
76
Yet with regard to 9/11, although RRRs might help explain lack of reports of radioactive fallout, it is questionable whether even multiple RRRs could account for the extent & kind of damage done to the WTC as well maintain hot spots in the ground at Ground Zero for 99 days.
77/
Media image
Media image
77
Besides the ER & RRR weapons, one wonder what other 3rd-gen nukes, these 5 nuclear states were able to secretly develop since the 1980s? After all, physicist Ted Taylor said confidently back in 1972 "If you want a bomb that spews out nothing but green paint, you can do that.”
78/
Media image
Media image
78
Taylor in his 1987 SciAm article suggested "shaped nuclear charges." He thought even nukes of very low yield w/many forms of energy of much higher intensities had far more opportunities to produce directional effects than "shaped chemical charges."
79/
Media image
Media image
Media image
79
Indeed in Apr 2017 presentation to London 9/11Keeptalking, physicist Heinz Pommer hypothesized THREE shaped 3rd-gen RRRs - in effect, nuclear directed energy weapons (NDEWs) - one each 25 m beneath lowest level of WTC1, WTC2 & WTC7 in the granite bedrock
80/
Media image
Media image
80
Pommer believed each NDEW was UNDER the tower b/c conservation of momentum dictates that only ONE energy source DEEPLY underground connected by a shaft to the surface could form the uniform eruption-like parabolic fountain of ejected material observed for both Twin Towers
81/
Media image
Media image
Media image
81
Pommer hypothesized it’s possible to choose preferred direction of x-ray/neutron flash by using Be-9 reflectors & Fe-56/Ni-58 X-plug (radiation lens) to pass neutron & X-rays up to the shaft which acts as a “collimator” focusing a powerful energy beam into each bldg’s core
82/
Media image
Media image
Media image
82
Based on sequence of events (e.g. 9 seconds btwn shockwave & eruption), weakness of shockwave & size of observed “melt cavities,” Pommer estimated 1st stage fission w/1 kt TNT equiv yield & 2nd stage "slow fusion"/nuclear fizzle (for about 5 seconds) w/26 kt yield
83/
Media image
Media image
83
Pommer then sketched out how his 3rd-gen RRR NDEW model explained what happened to the South Tower in the 15 seconds after detonation:
0.01 seconds: X-ray / neutron flash in the Tower
1 sec: X-ray softening the Tower's steel core
84/
911history.de/pdfs/911_Analy…
Media image
Media image
84
6 sec: Liquid rock chambers at max pressure, steel core softened, fusion terminated, high radioactivity levels in the melt cavity
8 sec: Bursting chambers & nuclear plasma upshot with 8,000 °C inside elevator shafts
9 sec: First visible eruption on top
15 sec: Full eruption
85/
Media image
Media image
Media image
Media image
85
Thus, after 3 years of testing his model, physicist Heinz Pommer had concluded that 3rd-gen Directed Energy/Minimum Residual Radiation nukes (10 kt max) were “the prime suspect for being used on 9/11”. In the rest of this thread I will defend that thesis agst its challengers.
86/
Media image
86
As convincing as Pommer had made case for 3rd-gen nukes, only a year later - after two professors (French & Swedish) contacted him summer 2017 - he had completely abandoned 3rd-gen idea as seen in his follow-up talk to London 9/11Keeptalking (May 2018)
87/
youtu.be/gxC_8Kuagcw?t=…
87
The communication that obviously troubled Pommer most was from the French prof who we can easily identify as François Roby, Physics Prof at Univ of Pau, since he later published the exact same analysis that Pommer discusses in 2018 London presentation
88/
hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-02004696v2…
Media image
Media image
Media image
88
Roby convinced Pommer "The Towers' destruction was a mere SIDE EFFECT of what happened in the rockbed!" b/c 90% energy expended at Ground Zero on 9/11 remained in the rock. Roby had calculated 10^15 J (240 kt TNT equiv) to maintain hot spots for 3 mos!
89/
youtu.be/gxC_8Kuagcw?t=…
Media image
Media image
89
240 kt TNT equiv would definitely be hard to account for w/Pommer's three 10 kt (max) 3rd-gen RRR NDEWs but before REJECTING the 3rd-gen model completely based on Roby's calculations - as Pommer does - we really should dig more deeply into the whole 9/11 bedrock energy issue.
90/
Media image
90
For one thing, Pommer had NOT been blissfully ignorant of the issue of energy input into the rock. Indeed, in his 2017 London talk, he had presented his own calculations for WTC7 but had come up with only 1.5 kt TNT equiv - much, much lower than Roby's 80 kt per tower!
91/
Media image
Media image
91
To come up with that 1.5 kt TNT equiv for WTC, Pommer used a "cooking plate" analogue calculating how much energy was used to heat the cooking plate to 300 C and then scaling up to a cooking plate the size of the hot spot where WTC7 used to be & comes up with 1.5 kt TNT eq.
92/
Media image
92
However, there are immediate problems with Pommer's calculation when you notice that he has the size of the WTC hot spot at 3,750,000 m²! Did he mean 3,750 m²? Then, in scaling up, he seems to assume the WTC hot spot to be the SAME THICKNESS as a regular cooking plate!
93/
Media image
Media image
93
To get a number like 1.5 kT for WTC7, I backcalculated a "similar" cylinder for WTC hot spot w/radius 42.3 m (529x cooking plate radius which seems a bit larger than the radius of the circle on the diagram) & hot spot height 529x cooking plate height.
94/
Media image
Media image
94
Curiously, in explaining how Roby came up w/80 kt per tower, Pommer shows this slide & says Roby used the same cooking plate analogue that Pommer had used the previous year! Did nobody (inc Pommer) question how the same analogue could give 1.5 kt one year & 80 kt the next?!
95/
Media image
95
Contrary to Pommer, Roby most definitely did NOT use a cooking plate analogue! But his method also raises a lot of questions. To come up with his "order of magnitude calculation" of 10^15 J for "total heat released at GZ", Roby multiplies four roughly estimated numbers.
96/
Media image
Media image
Media image
96
Total GZ heat release (per Roby) =
Total hot spot area (20,000 m²) x
ΔT avg hot spot & ambient temps on 9/11 (350 K) x
avg heat transfer coeff (10 W/m²K) x
"characteristic cooling time" (120 days) ~10^15 J ~240 kT TNT equiv
97/
Media image
Media image
97
To put this amount of energy in perspective, the HEAT released from EACH of the THREE hot spots would be equal to HEAT that would be released from a SOCCER PITCH maintaining 377 C/711 F for 120 days from 9/11 to 1/9/2002!
98/
Media image
Media image
Media image
98
The problem w/order of magnitude calculations is that the people doing them are NOT Enrico Fermi (they stop asking questions!) & can easily come up w/quite different estimates for hot spot area/depth, ΔT, etc. wch when multiplied together can readily lead to 1.5 kt or 80 kt.
99/
Media image
Media image
Media image
Media image
99
Indeed we need to question Prof Roby abt his own assumptions that his order of magnitude numbers reject every other nuclear 9/11 theory except his own suspect theory that only a 100 kt nuke buried at depth of ~100 m could have caused WTC7 "collapse"
100/

@drbairdonline
Bruce Baird@drbairdonline
UAF study concludes WTC7 collapse due to "a global failure involving the near-simultaneous failure of every column in the building." Here's another way you could do it. Underground nuclear demolition! Have WTC7 free fall into a footprint-sized crater!
/1
ine.uaf.edu/wtc7
100
Altho Pommer bought Roby's 10^15 J, he had years before rejected the deeply-buried-large-nuke theory (first proposed by Dimitri Khalezov) b/c it would have greatly damaged the "bathtub" wall. So he was left with a conundrum: "Some futuristic design - or old technology?"
101/
Media image
Media image
101
First we might consider briefly what would be involved in developing an RRR weapon. Although 3rd-gen details are classified, physicist Heinz Pommer has told me (by email) he believes the RRR/MRR design was essentially a modification of the earlier ENHANCED radiation design.
66/
Media image
102
Pommer didn't try to find some way to modify his current 3rd-gen theory to fit new data like scientists typically do. No, rather angrily - he didn't like to "waste" his time "thinking how the nuclear device actually worked" - he started from scratch.
102/
youtu.be/Se5BDbEbtwU?t=…
Media image
Media image
Media image
Media image
103
As he tells the story, Pommer found the solution - a 0th-generation (i.e., primitive) nuclear reactor bomb - inspired by learning abt a natural nuclear reactor in Gabun. "The devil's trick" was that the solution wasn't futuristic technology but a design taken from NATURE!
103/
Media image
Media image
Media image
Media image
104
The actual theory Pommer comes up with to replace his 3rd-gen 10-kt MRR NDEW theory is "a beryllium-polluted lump of weapons-grade uranium" that when activated by external neutron flash will heat & melt causingdenser U-235 to sink & purify, leading to nuclear fizzle.
104/
Media image
Media image
Media image
Media image
105
But Pommer does not really explain WHY a highly problematic 0th-gen nuclear reactor bomb was necessary. Does he really imagine the perpetrators he calls "killing psychopaths" couldn't have positions an ARRAY of 3rd-gen nukes around the WTC to account for all these phenomena?
105/
Media image
106
If there are observations of EMP in the hour(s) before "collapse" of the towers as Pommer observed in his 2018 London talk, how about a 3rd-gen EMP nuke that Andre Gsponer wrote scientists were working on back in 1982?
106/
Media image
Media image
Media image
107
And why try to come up with a way for three 0th-gen nuclear reactor bombs to do all the damage to WTC when multiple 3rd-gen weapons in WTC3, WTC4, WTC5 & WTC6. I mean what did cause those two 10-story cylindrical craters in 8-story WTC6?!
107/

@drbairdonline
Bruce Baird@drbairdonline
What's the greatest mystery about #WTC6?

1) Two 10-story craters in 8-story building?
2) Explosions at same time "second plane" hit?
3) Collapsed before either tower?
4) The missing gold?
5) Tritium in basement 55x normal background level?
6) The fact that nobody talks about it?
Media image
108
And if the problem is you need 80-150 kt TNT equiv energy input in the bedrock under each of the three towers or the size & location of "as-if-formerly-molten-rock-formations" (or are they glacier valleys?), how about multiple or larger 3rd-gen RRR nukes?
108/
Media image
Media image
Media image
Media image
109
But when the Swedish prof contacted Pommer summer 2017 abt 0.3 kt 4th-gen nuke that "could fire a nuclear plasma jet out of the earth" for several secs (before evaporating), Pommer rejected the idea saying the "main problem" was "the rockbed would not turn hot for so long"
109/
Media image
Media image
110
I should add this Swedish professor is undoubtedly Per Gunnar Berglund who has been promoting the idea that two 3rd-gen 0.3-0.4 kt NPLs (nuclear pumped laser) were used on 9/11, NOT 4th-gen as Pomer reports.
110/
swebbtv.se/images/pdf/201…
swebbtv.se/blogg/330-lord…
111
I'll just wrap this thread up reiterating my hypothesis that an array of 3rd-generation nukes - weapon of choice for nuclear states engaged in "the war OF terror" over last 40 years - should be the starting place for anybody interested in what really happened at WTC on 9/11.
111/
Media image
Media image
Actions
What You Can Do
  • Export as PDF or Markdown
  • Batch Export to Notion
  • Bookmark & Highlight
  • Screenshot Tweet
Create Free Account

Includes 7-day Premium trial

Advertisement