"it regularly happens that some random guy discovers something...

@DefenderOfBasic
Could Be Defender@DefenderOfBasic
25 views Sep 23, 2025 ~1 min read
Advertisement
1
"it regularly happens that some random guy discovers something before anyone in academia does" - the truth of this claim may be anywhere between 0% (easy for you to debunk) to 100% (very easy to prove).

The key: think about "how would you know if it were true?"
2
If it were true, then it should be easy to verify right? Because the claim isn't just that it happens, it happens a lot. So you should be able to find one yourself, firsthand.

But, how would you know if it was true? What even counts as "discovered something before academia"?
3
some crazy things are in the category of "if it were true, news would reach me". This is not one of those. This could be true but won't reach you. Do you see why?

(1) Who decides what counts as new knowledge?
(2) Who broadcasts that & records it?
4
To dumb it down, I'm saying: some crackpot schizo might genuinely have novel insights before anyone in academia, but it doesn't matter because they'll eventually get to it, and write it down. No prizes are awarded for the successful schizo
5
(i think the takeaway I want to drive towards is, this is the kind of question that is easy to verify, but it requires you either looking for yourself, or finding someone you trust to do that)
6
(the only open flaw in this chain of reasoning I'm unsatisfied with is "why can't you prove this retroactively?" and I have an answer to that but needs another thread. Requesting review from @evalladen @taijitu_sees )
Actions
What You Can Do
  • Export as PDF or Markdown
  • Batch Export to Notion
  • Bookmark & Highlight
  • Screenshot Tweet
Create Free Account

Includes 7-day Premium trial

Advertisement