I see this study is making the rounds. It raises some valid points...

But it certainly does not show "that Earth can safely store around 1,460 gigatons of carbon dioxide."
Let's look at what the study really says🧵

With that estimate, geologic storage could offset 0.7°C of warming. And as we know, every degree, or .1°C matters
Good news!
1. Language used by the authors in the study
2. Decisions made on exclusion criteria
3. Reporting/response by some people on here (not the author's fault)
I think what this paper actually does, or maybe what the title should be is "A reassessment of the lower level bounds of global sedimentary basin geologic storage based on abritrary exlucsion criteria focusing on harm prevention."
Those exclusions are important, as this study notes, peridotites alone have the capacity to store 100,000+ GtCO2
frontiersin.org/journals/clima…
But the point is that the study is titled, "A prudent planetary limit for geologic carbon storage" which is gives the impression it's...
It's a choice in language these authors made, I find it misleading, even though they qualify it in the study. We all know people don't read the study lol
Why is 25km chosen for the central case and not 50km or 100km.
I understand they do a sensitivity analysis but the main figure in the paper, and the thrust of the reporting, is on the central case.
It's a valid, but vibes-based choice.
We don't actually know the full extent of storage globally, but we do know, it's more than we have now.
David Wallace Wells (who I don't know) pulls a quote that doesn't include any of the context I laid out above. And it's immediately boosted across the site.
I don't know David's intention but the quote lacks context.













