“Telling someone to relax” almost never works. In fact, it usually...
Steve Magness@stevemagness
80 views
Aug 22, 2025
~2 min read
Advertisement
1
“Telling someone to relax” almost never works.
In fact, it usually backfires.
Why? The brain hears: “You must look stressed!”
And then it doubles down, amplifying anxiety.
The very thing meant to calm us ramps the system up.
In fact, it usually backfires.
Why? The brain hears: “You must look stressed!”
And then it doubles down, amplifying anxiety.
The very thing meant to calm us ramps the system up.
2
This happens because the brain is a meaning-making machine.
When someone says “relax,” it cues you to scan for stress.
You ask: Am I tense? Do I look anxious? What if others can see it?
That self-monitoring adds pressure instead of removing it.
Awareness turns into hyper-awareness.
When someone says “relax,” it cues you to scan for stress.
You ask: Am I tense? Do I look anxious? What if others can see it?
That self-monitoring adds pressure instead of removing it.
Awareness turns into hyper-awareness.
3
Think about the last time you were nervous before a big performance.
A coach or friend says: “Just calm down.”
Suddenly, you’re not only battling nerves...you’re battling the thought that you shouldn’t have nerves.
That secondary layer makes the stress feel even heavier.
It’s like trying to smother a fire with gasoline.
A coach or friend says: “Just calm down.”
Suddenly, you’re not only battling nerves...you’re battling the thought that you shouldn’t have nerves.
That secondary layer makes the stress feel even heavier.
It’s like trying to smother a fire with gasoline.
4
When we resists persists.
Psychology research shows that suppression actually increases physiological arousal.
Heart rate, skin conductance, muscle tension all rise.
Telling yourself not to feel something ironically makes you feel it more.
It’s the mental version of “don’t think of a pink elephant.”
The thought gets louder, not quieter.
Psychology research shows that suppression actually increases physiological arousal.
Heart rate, skin conductance, muscle tension all rise.
Telling yourself not to feel something ironically makes you feel it more.
It’s the mental version of “don’t think of a pink elephant.”
The thought gets louder, not quieter.
5
So what works better?
Clear, actionable cues that refocus attention on something you can control.
Drop your shoulders. Shake out your hands. Take a deep breath.
Simple, specific actions cut the loop of self-monitoring.
They give the brain something to do, not just something to avoid.
Clear, actionable cues that refocus attention on something you can control.
Drop your shoulders. Shake out your hands. Take a deep breath.
Simple, specific actions cut the loop of self-monitoring.
They give the brain something to do, not just something to avoid.
6
Once you’ve reset with a physical cue, tie it to a goal-directed action.
Runners might shift focus to hitting a smooth rhythm.
Basketball players might lock in on shooting
Public speakers might focus on the next story instead of the whole talk.
The mind steadies when it has a clear, concrete task.
Runners might shift focus to hitting a smooth rhythm.
Basketball players might lock in on shooting
Public speakers might focus on the next story instead of the whole talk.
The mind steadies when it has a clear, concrete task.
7
This isn’t about tricking yourself into calm.
It’s about redirecting attention away from threat and back toward execution.
Neuroscience shows that when the prefrontal cortex is occupied with controllable tasks, the amygdala’s fear signals lose intensity.
You create space to perform instead of spiraling into analysis.
Action restores agency.
It’s about redirecting attention away from threat and back toward execution.
Neuroscience shows that when the prefrontal cortex is occupied with controllable tasks, the amygdala’s fear signals lose intensity.
You create space to perform instead of spiraling into analysis.
Action restores agency.
8
Great coaches know this instinctively.
They don’t shout “relax” from the sidelines.
They give cues that ground athletes in the moment: “Loosen your grip. Focus on the target. Trust your form.”
The shift is subtle but profound.
It replaces vague reassurance with specific direction.
They don’t shout “relax” from the sidelines.
They give cues that ground athletes in the moment: “Loosen your grip. Focus on the target. Trust your form.”
The shift is subtle but profound.
It replaces vague reassurance with specific direction.
9
So the next time you—or someone you’re helping—feels pressure rising, skip the empty “relax.”
Instead, guide the focus to what’s controllable.
Loosen, breathe, anchor to the task.
Because calm isn’t commanded into existence.
It’s created through action, attention, and trust in the process.
Instead, guide the focus to what’s controllable.
Loosen, breathe, anchor to the task.
Because calm isn’t commanded into existence.
It’s created through action, attention, and trust in the process.
