Just an opinion... Gonna put JS index expiry manipulation aside. It...

Gonna put JS index expiry manipulation aside. It looks bad and if that was their intent it is bad.
But regarding the strategy where they sloppily buy deltas to turn around and sell option combos at artificially pumped prices...
realize that they aren't entitled to overestimate how much liquidity “last sale" represents
I mean as a market maker you are taught not to provide more delta liquidity in the options than the underlying so this isn't some profound suggestion
But they don't assume infinite liquidity at the bid or offer
This is not uncommon and every mm understands what this feels like.
If the put bid is juicy AND public you can assume everyone sees it
If a put has .05 vega and .50 delta, a mm might be willing to sell it for 1/2 vol point of edge. And they might assume say .02 cents slippage on the delta hedge...
2.5c for vol risk
1c for delta risk (ie .02 slippage x .5 delta)
So for some reason in India were retail traders just naively thinking they could take down all this optical delta edge because the index
Last sale is a construct of the past.
There seems to be some disconnect on what one can assume about "last sale" and I'm saying even a bid can be flaky.
If the index just ran up sloppily and someone wants to sell you calls, you should be hyper on guard that there's an air pocket below the bid.
And eventually the market will stop giving more liquidity in the options than the underlying.
It's self-correcting.
This shows up in market making cycles...
Markets are too tight.
The last people who got hired now get fired while the best ones replace their expensive bosses cycle repeats
Firms vary in their approach to the line
I don't think morality plays into it so much as legal and optics
For example, what's the morality of protecting overzealous retail traders who
I can't get my moral muscles activated for worrying about these people and think it's more upright to see the adversarial nature with clear eyes
In turn there's different types of markets to play in incentivizing their own behaviors and equilibrium