Just an opinion... Gonna put JS index expiry manipulation aside. It...

@KrisAbdelmessih
Kris@KrisAbdelmessih
18 views Jul 07, 2025 ~4 min read
Advertisement
1
Just an opinion...

Gonna put JS index expiry manipulation aside. It looks bad and if that was their intent it is bad.

But regarding the strategy where they sloppily buy deltas to turn around and sell option combos at artificially pumped prices...
2
The antitode is for the losers is to
realize that they aren't entitled to overestimate how much liquidity “last sale" represents

I mean as a market maker you are taught not to provide more delta liquidity in the options than the underlying so this isn't some profound suggestion
3
For example, if a market makers is seeing a bid for puts or call offers they are pricing the vol using the stock's bid (and vice versa, they use the offer if the option order is buying delta)

But they don't assume infinite liquidity at the bid or offer
4
In fact you might not even assume you can trade at the bid or offer. If the put bid looks very high compared to the stock bid a mm might invert "given that 30% vol is fair, the put bid implies the stock is 20 cents lower"...
5
In other words the derivative becomes the underlying. It tells you more about the underlying than the market in the stock.

This is not uncommon and every mm understands what this feels like.

If the put bid is juicy AND public you can assume everyone sees it
6
And that goes into your mental guess of where the stock price probably is...in fact the right move here is to just sell the stock bid and try to push the price discovery process knowing that you can "lean" on the put offer ...if you are fast, this is basically a "free roll"
7
Even my edge functions codify delta slippage.

If a put has .05 vega and .50 delta, a mm might be willing to sell it for 1/2 vol point of edge. And they might assume say .02 cents slippage on the delta hedge...
8
So if the put fair value is $1 then the mm is willing to sell at $1.035

2.5c for vol risk
1c for delta risk (ie .02 slippage x .5 delta)

So for some reason in India were retail traders just naively thinking they could take down all this optical delta edge because the index
9
last sale was some repository of truth for infinite shares.

Last sale is a construct of the past.

There seems to be some disconnect on what one can assume about "last sale" and I'm saying even a bid can be flaky.
10
I mean this is the whole essence of trading. Separating what's real from fake. Last sale <> fair value

If the index just ran up sloppily and someone wants to sell you calls, you should be hyper on guard that there's an air pocket below the bid.
11
So you get tagged and you learn, this is another way I can lose -- by assuming too much.

And eventually the market will stop giving more liquidity in the options than the underlying.

It's self-correcting.

This shows up in market making cycles...
12
Business gets good. High volume and vol. Trading firms expand,hire more option traders chasing last year's bonanza. Vol quiets down. Now top many sharps. The market making capacity exceeds the quantity of fish. Too many predators not enough prey.

Markets are too tight.
13
Savvy delta-smart customers run the market makers over. Punish them for being tighter than the underlying. Giving liquidity that the customers couldnt get in the stock

The last people who got hired now get fired while the best ones replace their expensive bosses cycle repeats
14
Anyway, all my opinions are irrelevant. The regulators are who matter. So trading firms usually try to understand their lines. They communicate with them. A practice that was once ok can become frowned upon even before it's made illegal.

Firms vary in their approach to the line
15
Some want to know how far they can go, others want to steer far away. It's all a risk/reward calc to them including reputation.

I don't think morality plays into it so much as legal and optics

For example, what's the morality of protecting overzealous retail traders who
16
get burned trying to swing trade option synthetics under the assumption that the lovely price they are being offered is free money.

I can't get my moral muscles activated for worrying about these people and think it's more upright to see the adversarial nature with clear eyes
17
You can disagree but my larger point is this isn't about morality. The regulators have objective functions around what a market should be and craft rules with them in mind.

In turn there's different types of markets to play in incentivizing their own behaviors and equilibrium
18
Fwiw, I see manipulating index prints very differently because it's like a choke point in a system and there's no clear counter like in the other manipulation like "just don't bid so aggressively for calls after someone pumped the stock"
19
There's also tremendous precedent for good reason against certain behaviors around cash settled expirations and they make sense because cash settlement is a discontinuous boundary (physical settlement into an instrument that continues to exist is a different matter)
20
To quote @tracyalloway let's leave it there
Actions
What You Can Do
  • Export as PDF or Markdown
  • Batch Export to Notion
  • Bookmark & Highlight
  • Screenshot Tweet
Create Free Account

Includes 7-day Premium trial

Advertisement