If you want a concrete understanding of the dialectic between "War...

@RedPrecariat
Sakā Koba ☭ 🏭 🌽@RedPrecariat
8 views May 21, 2025 ~1 min read
Advertisement
1
If you want a concrete understanding of the dialectic between "War of Position" and "War of Maneuver," you should study Ukraine's 2023 Offensive and the Russian defense.

The first map depicts the Ukrainian plan, and the second shows their actual gains (blue stripes, not arrows).
Media image
Media image
2
Don't ignore the granular details in favor of the big picture; that will only keep you trapped in the realm of abstraction.

Study the *particular* positions and maneuvers held and taken by each side during their summer struggle on the Pontic Steppe.
3
Every "War of Position" contains struggles to maneuver, and every "War of Maneuver" contains struggles for position.
4
Make sure to look up the phrase "correlation of forces and means" too. It's a simple but important concept to understand.
5
On those big arrow maps, it looks like the Russians were just holding positions, and the Ukrainians were just maneuvering—yet the Russian defense involved constant localized/tactical counterattacks to restore lost positions, and the Ukrainians had to defend those positions!
6
The Position/Maneuver dialectic occurs fractally, from the individual to the civilizational level.

This is why the Soviets called the dialectical resolution Operational ART and not Operational SCIENCE; coping with this layered complexity is a fundamentally creative endeavor.
7
It's easy for us members of the war commentariat to, for example, demand that Russia conduct big arrow offensives NOW—nobody understands the danger of that kind of impatience more than a soldier who is ordered to take a trench line with his squad.

Tunnel vision is deadly!
8
All the greatest fuckups in this war were either unwise offensive maneuvers (like Ukraine's 2023 offensive) or direct products of unwise offensive maneuvers (like Russia stretching itself thin before Ukraine's 2022 Kharkov offensive).
Actions
What You Can Do
  • Export as PDF or Markdown
  • Batch Export to Notion
  • Bookmark & Highlight
  • Screenshot Tweet
Create Free Account

Includes 7-day Premium trial

Advertisement