What's actually happening with the Gaza death toll? Thousands of...

@_BvdM
Ben van der Merwe@_BvdM
14 views May 04, 2025 ~1 min read
Advertisement
1
What's actually happening with the Gaza death toll?

Thousands of people have been removed since August, including 1,800 since October.
Media image
2
Those yellow bits above are the removal of entries originating not from hospital morgue records, but from an online form.

This form allows families to submit deaths without a body. When it get verified by a judicial committee, they are eligible to receive social assistance.
Media image
3
Zaher Wahidi, the head of Gaza health ministry's statistics bureau, says that until October these entries were included prior to judicial verification.

This led to a bunch of false entries being included, so from October they removed all unverified entries pending checks.
Media image
4
We previously thought that the names from the form were already verified, but Wahidi says this is only true since October.

A health ministry doc from July 2024 confirms this.

As @Michael_Spagat says, this definitely means earlier lists were less reliable than we thought.
Media image
5
Crucially, however, the removals have had very little impact on the share of women and children killed.

The total effect of all removals has been to *reduce* the share of women, children and elderly very slightly, from 56.2% to 55.9%.
Media image
6
This is not what we'd expect to see if the removals were part of a deliberate plot to fiddle the numbers.

As @GabrielEpsteinX says: "If 90% of the removed entries were men aged 18-40, that would look like manipulation. But it doesn’t look like that."
7
Of all people ever added to the list, 7% have been removed.

About half were removed en masse because they come from the list (not bc they were proven false).

These will likely be re-added after checks, meaning the overall effect on the numbers will be small (4-5%).
8
Read the full analysis here news.sky.com/story/hundreds…
Actions
What You Can Do
  • Export as PDF or Markdown
  • Batch Export to Notion
  • Bookmark & Highlight
  • Screenshot Tweet
Create Free Account

Includes 7-day Premium trial

Advertisement