🚨Replication alert🚨 Do vaccinated children have higher income as...

aeaweb.org/articles?id=10…
2/
So why is there variation in reported incidence, if actual incidence is ~100% everywhere?
4/
(1) States differ in reporting capacity. Better health care, report a larger fraction of cases.
(2) States with worse initial health have more severe measles cases, and more severe cases are more likely to be reported.
5/
But in (1), it's not clear why states with better reporting capacity would benefit more from the vaccine.
6/
aeaweb.org/articles?id=10…
7/
The paper doesn't run an event study to test for pre-trends, so I do it.
8/
The treatment dose is access to the vaccine, which is 0 for cohorts born before 1949, increases by 1 per year until 1964, and is 16 afterwards.
9/
Born 1950: 2 years access
...
Born 1964: 16 out of 16 years of access.
10/
Eg. people born after 1964 have the same vaccine access (full), so the effect should be the same from 1964-80.
11/
This doesn't mean that the vaccine failed. On the contrary:
But it does mean that this research design works better for diseases like malaria.
13/
See here for the writeup:
michaelwiebe.com/assets/atwood/…
I'll be submitting this to AEJ:EP as a comment. Atwood didn't respond to emails.
14/
- testing for a trend break in the event study
- the event study for disease outcomes
- heterogeneous effects, and more
michaelwiebe.com/assets/atwood/…
15/
patreon.com/michael_wiebe
If you have research you want to see scrutinized, please get in touch:
michaelwiebe.com/hire-me/
16/16





