1/ Get a cup of coffee. In this thread, I'll walk you through one...

@10kdiver
10-K Diver@10kdiver
26 views Sep 30, 2024 ~7 min read
Advertisement
1
1/

Get a cup of coffee.

In this thread, I'll walk you through one of Charlie Munger's greatest insights:

In the long term, the return an investor gets from a business will roughly equal the return the business itself earns on its capital.
2
2/

In the book Poor Charlie's Almanack, there's a wonderful chapter called Elementary Worldly Wisdom.

That chapter contains this beautiful nugget:
Media image
3
3/

Of all the things I've learned from Charlie Munger, this nugget has had the greatest impact on me.

Once I worked out the logic behind it, I never looked at businesses or investing the same way again.

And in this thread, I want to share this logic with you.
4
4/

Here, Charlie is comparing the long-term returns an investor will get by simply buying and holding 2 different businesses.

The first one is a Fair business. It earns 6% on capital each year. Let's call it F (for Fair).
5
5/

The second is a Wonderful business. It earns 18% per year on its capital.

Let's call this business W (for Wonderful).
6
6/

Here's how Charlie thinks about F and W.

Each of these businesses has some "capital" in it. This is money invested into the business by its owners.

Each business proceeds to earn a "return" on this capital every year. These are the "earnings" produced by each business.
7
7/

The key difference between F and W is that F earns only 6% on its capital every year, whereas W earns 18%.

Thus, for the same amount of *capital*, W is able to produce 3 times as much *earnings* as F.
8
8/

For example, if we start off both F and W with $1M of capital, F will earn 6% of $1M = $60K in its first year.

But in the same year, W will earn $180K -- 3 times as much as F.
9
9/

But that's not all.

The crucial thing is: Both F and W *re-invest* their earnings back into their own operations -- so they can grow these very earnings over time.
10
10/

That is, after 1 year, F will have its original $1M *plus* its $60K earnings = a total of $1.06M of capital to work with.

And W will have $1.18M.

So, in its 2'nd year, F will earn 6% of $1.06M = $63.6K -- up from $60K.

And W will earn 18% of $1.18M = $212.4K.

And so on.
11
11/

Here's a quick picture of this model:
Media image
12
12/

The upshot is that F is able to grow its earnings only at 6% per year, whereas W grows at 18% per year.

For example, here's a 30-year simulation of both F and W -- starting with the same $1M of capital.

By Year 30, F is earning ~$325K. But W is earning ~$22M!
Media image
13
13/

But of course, just because a *business* earns X% per year on capital, it doesn't mean an *investor* holding the business will enjoy the same X% per year return on his investment.

The investor's return will also depend on the *price* at which he buys and sells the business.
14
14/

But here's Charlie's key insight:

Over *long* periods of time, the investor's purchase and sale prices just don't matter very much.

The investor will end up getting more or less X% per year -- same as the underlying business -- *regardless* of his entry/exit price.
15
15/

What this means is: even if an investor is able to buy F at a very attractive price (say, a low P/E ratio), the advantage of striking this bargain erodes over time.

So, over time, the investor's return will tend to gravitate towards the business's mediocre 6% per year.
16
16/

And by the same token, even if an investor pays an optically high P/E multiple for W, the *disadvantage* of this steep price also erodes over time -- and the investor's return will again gravitate towards the business's wonderful 18% per year.
17
17/

For example, suppose we buy F at a "cheap" forward P/E of 8.

And after 30 years, we sell it at a robust forward P/E of 20.

In spite of our low purchase price and 2.5x multiple expansion, our 30-year return is only ~9.28% annualized.

Over 30 years, that's $1 becoming $14.
Media image
18
18/

On the other hand, let's say we buy W at an "expensive" 50 P/E.

And after 30 years, we sell it at a much lower 20 P/E.

In spite of our high purchase price and 2.5x multiple *contraction*, we still get a ~14.45% annualized return over 30 years -- turning $1 into $57!
Media image
19
19/

That's what Charlie is saying.

Over long periods of time, business quality (as measured by return on capital and reinvestment opportunities) always trumps purchase/sale timing, entry/exit multiples, etc.

And here's the math behind it:
Media image
20
20/

Here's a visualization of the 30-year return an investor gets from holding F and W -- for various entry and exit multiples.

Red = Poorer returns, Green = Better returns.

As we can see, it's hard to do really well with F or really badly with W. Exactly Charlie's point.
Media image
21
21/

As Buffett likes to say, it's far better to buy a wonderful business at a fair price than a fair business at a wonderful price.

And Charlie, of course, played a key role in helping Buffett reach this conclusion.
22
22/

One point I want to stress:

For a business to qualify as "wonderful", high returns on capital *alone* aren't enough.

The business should also have plenty of *re-investment opportunities* -- ie, high returns on both *legacy* capital and *incremental* capital.
23
23/

Only then will be business be able to complete the positive feedback loop above -- ie, take its high earnings and re-invest them at similarly high returns to grow these very earnings at a fast clip.
24
24/

This "scope for re-investment" makes a big difference.

Many large companies enjoy high returns on *legacy* capital. But their growth tends to stall over time -- so eventually, they only see limited opportunities for *re-investing* earnings.
25
25/

For example, let's consider a third business M.

Like W, M earns 18% per year on capital.

But the problem is: after 10 years, M's re-investment opportunities partially dry up. So, it re-invests only half its earnings (at 18%), returning the other half as dividends:
Media image
26
26/

Clearly, M is less wonderful than W -- as it's unable to sustain its re-investment rate beyond 10 years.

But it's easy to mistake a "type M" business for a "type W" business. After all, both have 10 years of 18% growth ahead. And predicting the future beyond that is hard!
27
27/

So, what happens if we make this mistake, pay 50x earnings for M now, and are able to sell out only at 20x after 30 years?

With W, the numbers worked out OK. We got a 30-year ~14.45% return.

But with M, our return (even including dividends) drops to ~10.04%.
28
28/

Instead of $1 to $57, we have $1 to $18.

So, if a business is truly wonderful, we can pay up for it and still do very well long-term.

But if the business turns out less wonderful than expected, paying up can hurt us.

So, we should be careful when paying fancy prices!
Media image
29
29/

It was during last year's Memorial Day weekend that I posted my first "get a cup of coffee" thread.

Words cannot describe how much your steadfast support and encouragement have meant to me since then.

Please stay safe. Enjoy your weekend!

/End
0:06
30
@IrnestKaplan 2/

Regarding holding M for 10 years, I believe this is a core component of our job as investors — to constantly monitor our portfolio companies for material changes in their economic characteristics.
31
@IrnestKaplan 3/

Based on this, if we conclude that forward returns aren’t likely to be very good relative to other opportunities we know of, then it may be time to exit the position and re-deploy our capital elsewhere.

/End
Actions
What You Can Do
  • Export as PDF or Markdown
  • Batch Export to Notion
  • Bookmark & Highlight
  • Screenshot Tweet
Create Free Account

Includes 7-day Premium trial

Advertisement