Debunking the lies mentioned in this picture against the Best of...

69 views Jan 21, 2026 ~6 min read

Debunking the lies mentioned in this picture against the Best of Creation, our master Muhammad (peace be upon him) | Thread 🧵

Greentext Poster@GreenTextRepost

submission by @shadyindividu4l

                            2
                        
"gives several prophecies which don't come true"

That claim is simply false. The prophecies of the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) were fulfilled with remarkable and well-documented accuracy. I have written detailed threads highlighting some of these prophecies

                            3
                        
Here are several threads I’ve written that document hundreds of fulfilled prophecies. Taken together, they constitute clear evidence that the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) was a true prophet:

Abdullah Amin@abduallah_amin

The Foretold Future: 14 Prophecies That Prove Muhammad ﷺ Was a True Prophet | thread (🧵)

Abdullah Amin@abduallah_amin

Detailed Refutation of the Last point | Thread 🧵

𝑷𝒓𝒐𝒑𝒉𝒆𝒄𝒊𝒆𝒔 𝒂𝒓𝒆 𝒍𝒂𝒄𝒌𝒊𝒏𝒈? 🤔💭

Let’s test it & see!

{And declare, “The truth has come and falsehood has vanished. Indeed, falsehood is bound to vanish.”} [the Qurʾān 17:81]

1/8

                            6
                        
"claims to be the final prophet of God"

Yes, because he is. The evidence above establishes that he was a true prophet, and once that is established, whatever a true prophet states about prophethood and its finality must also be true.

                            7
                        
This follows naturally and straightforwardly, saying that he merely claimed this as if it were an argument against him is strange. If he is a true prophet (as the evidence shows) then there is nothing problematic or objectionable about him being the final prophet. Not an argument

"Performs zero miracles"

That is also false. The Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) performed numerous miracles, so many that some scholars counted them in the hundreds, even approaching a thousand, and dedicated entire volumes to documenting them.

These two articles provide a solid discussion of this topic regarding miracles.
1/
yaqeeninstitute.org/read/paper/the…

2/
tulabassuffa.wordpress.com/2021/01/23/a-c…

                            10
                        
Moreover, the hundreds of prophecies he made that were later fulfilled are themselves miraculous and stand as powerful proofs of his blessed prophethood.

Once again, what is presented as an argument against Islam ends up becoming a proof in its favor. Just like the first one.

                            11
                        
“dies by having his aorta cut”

I’ve complied an entire playlist addressing this claim from every angle, carefully debunking it with references, while also showing how the argument can actually be turned into a proof of Islam.

particularly in how the Prophet ﷺ was not affected by the poison in the same way his companions were. If you’re sincere, you can explore the playlist here for yourself:

youtube.com/playlist?list=…

This is the third "argument" to be turned into a proof in his favor (PBUH)

                            13
                        
“false scientific theories”
This is nothing more than an empty claim. If anything, Islam is far more compatible with scientific discoveries than most other religions, so much so that one of the main reasons many people convert to Islam is the scientific accuracy they observe

                            14
                        
in its sources. While I don’t personally agree with every argument made in this area, many of them are valid. Overall, this point clearly shows that Islam aligns with scientific observation rather than contradicting it, making it a point in favor of Islam, not against it.

“no other prophet foretold his coming”

This is utterly false. I have an entire playlist of over 200 videos documenting numerous prophecies that foretold the coming of the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him).

You can watch some of them here:
youtube.com/playlist?list=…

I also highly recommend this excellent book, which details the prophecies foretelling the coming of the Prophet Muhammad ﷺ

                            17
                        
Far from being an argument against him, this becomes a fifth argument in his favor.

Moreover, this isn’t even a valid criterion to begin with. The truth of a prophet does not depend on whether others foretold him beforehand, so even setting the evidence aside, this claim fails.

                            18
                        
‘Talked to demons’

that’s simply false, and even if it were true, there’s no logical reason why communicating with ‘demons’ would make someone a false prophet. The Prophet (PBUH) received revelation through angels and was granted access to certain aspects of the unseen by God.

‘Didn’t convince any serious theologian’

this is simply untrue. Many early converts to Islam were knowledgeable scholars of other religions.

The Karaite Jew Yūsuf al-Baṣīr acknowledged the persuasive power of Islamic proofs in attracting converts:

Abdullah Amin@abduallah_amin

The Karaite Jew, Yūsuf al-Baṣīr, was troubled by the effectiveness of Islamic polemic in obtaining converts.

Yūsuf al-Baṣīr:

“Many from among us who converted found that the Muslims had argued elegantly concerning the prophecy of their master [Muḥammad ﷺ]…

1/3

The Jewish scholar al-Samaw‘al ibn Yahya al-Maghribi embraced Islam, citing the linguistic miracle of the Qurʾān as the reason he recognized its divine origin.

So this claim actually contradicts the historical record. I could share endless more examples.

Abdullah Amin@abduallah_amin

The Jewish scholar al-Samaw'al ibn Yahya al-Maghribi, who embraced Islam, speaks about the linguistic miracle of the Qurʾān and how it was the reason for his belief in the divine origin of the Qurʾān.

Even recently, the distinguished Oxford theologian Keith Ward stated that not only does he recognize Muhammad ﷺ as a prophet, but so do all of his colleagues in theology, keep in mind he is referring to scholars at the highest academic institutions.
Link:
youtube.com/shorts/aTa_l0E…

‘Illiterate’

this isn’t an argument against him. In fact, it’s a proof in the Prophet’s favor. The Qur’an is universally recognized as the most eloquent text in Arabic, even by non-Muslim scholars (see the thread below).

Abdullah Amin@abduallah_amin

Thread 🧵 :
Multitudes of scholars from western, eastern, religious and non-religious backgrounds have testified to the Qur’an’s inimitability. Below is a non-exhaustive list of the scholarship that forms the testimony that the Qur’an cannot be emulated [non muslims list] :⬇️

                            23
                        
How could someone unlettered produce something of such unmatched linguistic mastery? It’s like claiming that someone who never attended English classes wrote the Oxford English Dictionary, Far from a weakness this is actually miraculous, another supposed ‘con’ turned into a proof

                            24
                        
‘Lived an unholy carnal life’
No proof or argument given, utterly false. The Prophet ﷺ led a life of complete moral integrity, honesty, and self-restraint. His companions and even his enemies testified to his exemplary character, calling him al-Amin, the Trustworthy.

Every aspect of his life (his worship, family life, dealings with others) was in accordance with the highest ethical standards. What’s being presented as a ‘criticism’ is actually a testament to his unmatched virtue and moral purity.

I recommend reading this book on this:

Here’s a link to a free PDF of this book, it beautifully illustrates how the Prophet Muhammad ﷺ interacted with all kinds of people throughout his life. I promise, if you read it fully, you will be captivated and fall in love with his character.

d1.islamhouse.com/data/en/ih_boo…

                            27
                        
The last claim in that picture, that the Prophet ﷺ was 'ignorant' about Christianity and Judaism, is simply false. The Quran contains incredibly detailed accounts of prophets and other religious knowledge that were completely unknown in Arabia at the time.

                            28
                        
In fact, the Quran itself uses this as evidence against the people of Makkah, showing that they had no knowledge of these details, so how could the Prophet ﷺ have known them?

This has led some Orientalists to invent wild conspiracy theories to explain it away naturally, because the truth is simply miraculous when you reflect on it. Here’s a good thread that explores this point further and how it actually proves Islam:

Seeking Eternity@SeekingEternals

The Qur’ān That Drove Them Mad | thread 🧵

Here are all the claims made against the Prophet peace be upon him, and how we’ve shown that they are false, and that, in fact, the truth behind each of them proves his Prophethood:

                            31
                        
So from these accusations, we’ve actually uncovered almost ten clear proofs of his Prophethood. I’ve always found it remarkable that most arguments used against Islam, when investigated properly, turn into proofs for it.

                            32
                        
It breaks my heart that this very misleading and misinformation-filled meme had 20k likes and so many views, but my duty is to clear the misconceptions. We shouldn’t be surprised that social media can be a place where misinformation spreads and is even celebrated.

                            33
                        
I pray that Allah (Exalted and Mighty) accepts my efforts in defending His noble Prophet peace be upon him, and I pray that this becomes a means for me to attain the intercession of the beloved Prophet peace be upon him on the Day of Judgment, ameen.

Debunking the lies mentioned in this picture against the Best of...

Actions

What You Can Do

Actions

What You Can Do

More in Science & Research