🧵What’s happening in Argentina? For days, my WhatsApp has been...

@SFGaliani
Sebastian Galiani@SFGaliani
15 views Sep 19, 2025 ~2 min read
Advertisement
1
🧵What’s happening in Argentina?
For days, my WhatsApp has been blowing up with messages asking the same thing. Why is the dollar glued to the top of the band? Why did country risk suddenly spike 500 points? Here's a quick thread with some thoughts.👇
2
The immediate cause is political. Polls for the midterms no longer show a clear win for President Milei. He still leads—but narrowly. And after the Kirchnerist-Marxist governor Kicillof defeated the government in key provincial elections, markets began to doubt the political viability of Milei’s program.
3
In Argentina, when reformist governments lose at the ballot box, their programs get reversed. If Milei looks unlikely to win re-election in 2027, investment stalls, the economy stays stagnant—and that stagnation makes his defeat even more likely.
But if his coalition wins decisively in October, the dollar could drop back to the middle of the band (and then float), and country risk would likely fall by at least the 500 points it just spiked—if not more.
4
Argentina is notoriously hard to reform. Reformist governments pay high costs early, while gains only arrive later—once investors believe the public will support the program long term. But here’s the dilemma: midterms come just two years in. If reformers lose them, the program dies before it bears fruit.
5
This dynamic pushes reformist governments to front-load disinflation. Lowering inflation is always good—but in Argentina, the timing becomes political. To gain support before midterms, governments often over-appreciate the exchange rate.
Economists debate these moves technically, but their true logic is political: survival. Without it, reforms can’t continue—and growth never returns.
6
Other countries face similar dilemmas—never say never.
But in Argentina, the coalition that could bring back economic populism remains stubbornly large, even after 50 years of per capita income decline. Reformists tend to win only at the brink—or during hyperinflation. As soon as the pain eases, support begins to slip away.
7
On top of that, Argentina’s corporatist institutions—unions, business lobbies, entrenched bureaucracies—have survived for decades. Their mission is to defend privileges, not promote growth. They are, as we say, a hard bone to crack.
8
This isn’t to say reformist governments don’t make mistakes—all governments do. But obsessing over them ex post often misses the point. These are second-order problems. The real obstacle is the recurring dilemma: how to reform under the constant shadow of economic populism’s return. It’s not impossible—but it’s getting harder each time.
9
Whether Argentina can break this cycle will depend not just on sound economic policy, but on political clarity and social patience. Reform takes time—but Argentina’s history shows it rarely gets it.

I hope President Milei wins the midterm with a margin strong enough to protect the core of his plan, unlock investment, and allow deeper reforms to follow.
Actions
What You Can Do
  • Export as PDF or Markdown
  • Batch Export to Notion
  • Bookmark & Highlight
  • Screenshot Tweet
Create Free Account

Includes 7-day Premium trial

Advertisement