Who is the BEST Manchester United midfielder: Bruno, Mbeumo, or...

If you’re reading this thread, you probably want a decent FPL season. The smartest move right now is to sign-up to the LazyFPL newsletter, a 4 minute email before every deadline.
It’s totally FREE⬇️
lazyfpl.com/subscribe?utm_…
2 games against the promoted sides, both at Old Trafford
Brentford game a good game as well. Chelsea and City can cause problems but United will always be up for a derby, especially the latter 2 of which it’s their first derby. City also didn’t look anywhere near impressive in GW2 Vs Tottenham
Last season: 8G & 12A
Underlying data: 9.93 xG & 7.89 xA
93 shots, 26 SoT
Strengths: On Penalties
Takes direct FKs and some corners/indirect FKs
Defcon (reached once and 1 off in GW1)
Weaknesses:
Poor start
Team role – playing deeper, and even with substitutions he doesn’t get moved. Mount and Bruno were the pivot Vs Fulham for a brief period
Expensive at £9m – Mbeumo and Cunha are both £1m cheaper
Last season: 15G & 6A
Underlying data: 8.6 xG & 8.6 xA
110 shots, 44 SoT
Strengths:
Bonus point magnet – 41 bonus last season – Basically needed a return to guarantee 3 bonus points
Eye test – Strong positive as I haven’t seen the same from Bruno or Mbeumo as of yet. When Cunha plays as a fully fledged 10, I see a more dangerous player, who can play between the lines and exploit/stretch opposition lines
Not being on penalties doesn’t affect him, as he took 0 last season
Weaknesses:
Overperformance – 4th biggest xG overperformer in Europe’s top 5 leagues. How sustainable is this? Not very at the current difference (+6.27), even for some of the world’s best finishers
Last season: 20G & 9A
Underlying data: 12.52 xG & 9.24 xA
79 shots, 34 SoT
Strengths:
Flat track bully – Managed to get high points in all of the games against promoted teams bar 1 Vs Leicester
Instinct – Not developed a killer instinct yet, but Grimsby and Burnley can help with this. Bruno and Cunha don’t have this to near the same level
Weaknesses:
Loss of Penalties – 5 of his 20 goals were penalties (equivalent to 20 points excluding bonus points)
Overperformance: 2nd biggest xG overperformance in Europe’s top 5 leagues (+7.48)
This is the lineup I expect for Burnley on Sunday, Shaw could be Heaven, and Mainoo could be Casemiro
But enough about that, the big talking point for the 3 midfieders in question is actually Benjamin Sesko
Having come off the bench in both of United’s premier league games so far, Cunha, Mbeumo, and Bruno’s roles may vary, especially the first 2
Cunha will be able to drop deeper and help build up play in tight spaces compared to being forced central due to no striker
In my opinion, playing striker for these 2 harms more than it helps, as neither are naturals in the position. Bruno wise, there’s another passing option but less reason for him to get forward
Mbeumo = 19
Cunha = 10
Bruno = 8
You can clearly see how the lack of a prominent striker affects United, but you can also see Mbeumo the most far forward. The only issue? His width will change throughout the game due to the link up with Amad (right footed right wing back)
Cunha when he is in the left 10 won’t have the issue of Width due to Dorgu, who is a left footed left wing back, occupying that space
Bruno doesn’t appear to be going into the 10 anytime soon, and at times stayed in the double pivot, even with Mount at one point. Sure, there’s Defcon but I’d want a lot more than that for a £9m asset
In general, this was the better performance, and the graphic shows that. More space covered
Cunha a lot more forward this time, the furthest in fact. When Dalot plays, Mbeumo has more freedom yet also no support on the wing. Bruno played a bit further forward but still was used deeper than most would like.
The problem? If Parker operates a low block, it could cause frustration, similar to the arsenal game. Despite having 22 shots, they couldn’t find a way through.
The way United play, trying to capitalise in transition, doesn’t work as well against a low block, as we saw against Ipswich both times last season.
npxG: Non-Penalty expected goals
🥇 Cunha – 0.8
🥈 Mbeumo – 0.4
🥉 Bruno – 0.2
xA: expected assists
🥇 Mbeumo – 0.4
🥈 Bruno – 0.2
🥉 Cunha – 0.1
Shots on target:
🥇 Cunha – 4
🥈 Mbeumo – 2
🥉 Bruno – 1
Shots:
🥇 Cunha – 7
🥈 Mbeumo – 5
🥉 Bruno – 3
*Average shot distance felt relevant so (all in yards)
Bruno = 27.6
Mbeumo = 14.1
Cunha = 17.7
Bruno ✅✅✅
Cunha ❌ ❌ ❌
Mbeumo ❌✅✅
My favourite Manchester United asset is Matheus Cunha, and that is largely due to the eye test. When you watch him, he almost looks like he’s going to return every game
Another reason why is because of BONUS POINTS. Every time he returned last season, he got bonus, most of the time 3
A lot of people mention Mbeumo’s record against the promoted teams, but Cunha’s is still great. Against promoted teams, he got 4G and 3A in 4 games.
Combining this with his knack for returning in some bigger games, I quite like his prospects, especially over the medium term
I want to guarantee ahigh ceiling for my players, and a good role in their system, Bruno doesn’t really fill me with confidence for either of them.
I really like Mbeumo as a differential… 7G & 3A against the promoted teams, and I expect a goal vs Burnley. My only issue is I haven’t seen enough of that killer instinct yet to fully convince me.
United play Grimsby tonight so maybe we see something worthwhile. Even if we do… or don’t, take it with a pinch of salt, as the game is a lot different to a full pressure game I the league
They helped so big thnkas to him, give it a try!
This was a fun thread to write. If you have any threads like this with players to compare, tell me below 👇
It doesn't matter if they are different positions or from different teams ✅

Find out in this thread 🧵
Follow me @_TalkFPL 👈








