For those who like easy to digest versions. This is the story of...

@anto_ty
Ty Ngachira@anto_ty
11 views Jul 04, 2025 ~3 min read
Advertisement
1
For those who like easy to digest versions.
This is the story of Salim Juma Hakeem Kitendo. Salim was a Muslim man from Mombasa. He died in 2015. He left land. Houses. A business. And a divided family

At the centre of the dispute were three women and nine children

(thread)
@ahmednasirlaw
Ahmednasir Abdullahi SC@ahmednasirlaw
ITS NOW OFFFICIAL. MUSLIM PERSONAL LAW IS UNCONSTITUTIONAL IN KENYA!
The Supreme Court of Kenya's interpretation of Article 24(4) of Constitution in paragraphs 38, 39, 40, 41, 42, 43, 44, 45, 46, 47, 48, 49, 50, 51, 52, 53, 54 DECLARED ISLAMIC PERSONAL LAW UNCONSTITUTIONAL AND UNAPPLICABLE IN KENYA. This is the most RADICAL DECISION ever, and its EXPESS PROHIBITION of ISLAMIC PERSONAL LAW IN KENYA IS SEISMIC AND FAR REACHING. The PROHIBITION of MUSLIM PERSONAL LAW IN KENYA will have a profound political and societal implications in Kenya.
@WilliamsRuto @HonAdenDuale @HassanAliJoho @AbdikadirMohami @Nathif_J_Adam @BillowKerrow @JunetMohamed @CJMarthaKoome @taibalitaib
Media image
2
First there was Fatuma Athman Abud Faraj. His wife under Islamic law. She had four children with Salim and was the only woman he formally married in a nikah

She insisted that only her children should inherit. Because they were born in wedlock. Because that is what Sharia says
3
Then there was Rose Faith Mwawasi. She had lived with Salim before he married Fatuma. They had four children during those years. Years before she converted to Islam. Years before they had a nikah of their own

But when Salim died, none of that was written down. No will.
4
Enter Judith Malele Mwawasi

She was Rose’s sister-in-law. And when Fatuma moved to take control of the estate Judith saw what was coming

She saw children being written out of their father’s legacy.
5
So Judith joined Rose and together they went to court. They petitioned to administer the estate. To protect the four children of Rose. To make sure they were not erased from their father’s name

Judith didn’t come to claim. She came to shield. That was her role from the beginning
6
And they were not alone

There was also Marlin Coram Pownall. She had one child with Salim. No marriage. But still a child who bore his blood

She too joined the case to defend her child’s right to inherit
7
The case began in the High Court. Fatuma objected. Said Islamic law was clear. Only children from a valid marriage could inherit. The rest were not lawful heirs

But Judith and Rose said the Constitution was also clear. All children are equal. All have a right to be recognized
8
The High Court agreed with them. So did the Court of Appeal. But Fatuma took the matter to the Supreme Court

There the question came to a head

Can a child born outside wedlock to a Muslim father be excluded from inheritance under Kenyan law
9
The Supreme Court said no

It ruled that children cannot be punished for the circumstances of their birth. That Article 27 protects them from discrimination. That Article 53 says their best interests come first. And that no religious law can override that
10
The Court acknowledged that Muslims may be governed by Islamic personal law under Article 170. But it made one thing clear

All personal law must still obey the Constitution

And if that law harms a child it will not stand
11
The estate of Salim Juma Hakeem Kitendo was returned to the High Court. This time with orders to redistribute it to all his children

Four with Fatuma. Four with Rose. One with Marlin

All of them recognized as heirs. None of them left behind
12
In conclusion, the court said. If there is a conflict between religious tradition and the rights of a child as per the constitution, the Constitution wins

Every time
Actions
What You Can Do
  • Export as PDF or Markdown
  • Batch Export to Notion
  • Bookmark & Highlight
  • Screenshot Tweet
Create Free Account

Includes 7-day Premium trial

Advertisement