@nntaleb ↔ @Heinonmatti conversation

Nassim Nicholas Taleb@nntaleb
42 views
Jun 14, 2025
~1 min read
Advertisement

Nassim Nicholas Taleb@nntaleb
Raissa D'Souza did a whole shtick on "black swans" and "dragon kings", misdefining the terms (better read books before bloviating):
Her Black Swans are what I called Grey Swans, emerging from a fat-tailed probability distribution w/tractable properties.
Her dragon kings are Black Swans.

Her Black Swans are what I called Grey Swans, emerging from a fat-tailed probability distribution w/tractable properties.
Her dragon kings are Black Swans.

Carlos Gershenson@cgershen
#Criticality on networks: universality classes, power laws, and Dragon Kings by Raissa D’Souza #CCS2021

Nassim Nicholas Taleb@nntaleb
2)A Black Swan for the turkey is a white swan for the butcher.
If there is no objective definition of Black Swan (that is it would either be a Black Swan for all or nobody) it is because it depends on the observer and the body of knowledge before its occurrence.
It is epistemic.
If there is no objective definition of Black Swan (that is it would either be a Black Swan for all or nobody) it is because it depends on the observer and the body of knowledge before its occurrence.
It is epistemic.

matti heino@Heinonmatti
Nassim, what's your take on Sornette's view of black swans?
They have a new paper that came out last week: "Multiple outlier detection in samples with exponential & Pareto tails" tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.10…
Image from wiki page: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dragon_ki…
They have a new paper that came out last week: "Multiple outlier detection in samples with exponential & Pareto tails" tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.10…
Image from wiki page: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dragon_ki…

Nassim Nicholas Taleb@nntaleb
Bullshit. Straw man.


