@nntaleb ↔ @Heinonmatti conversation

@nntaleb
Nassim Nicholas Taleb@nntaleb
42 views Jun 14, 2025 ~1 min read
Advertisement
@nntaleb
Nassim Nicholas Taleb@nntaleb
Raissa D'Souza did a whole shtick on "black swans" and "dragon kings", misdefining the terms (better read books before bloviating):
Her Black Swans are what I called Grey Swans, emerging from a fat-tailed probability distribution w/tractable properties.

Her dragon kings are Black Swans.
@cgershen
Carlos Gershenson@cgershen
#Criticality on networks: universality classes, power laws, and Dragon Kings by Raissa D’Souza #CCS2021
Media image
Media image
@nntaleb
Nassim Nicholas Taleb@nntaleb
2)A Black Swan for the turkey is a white swan for the butcher.
If there is no objective definition of Black Swan (that is it would either be a Black Swan for all or nobody) it is because it depends on the observer and the body of knowledge before its occurrence.
It is epistemic.
@Heinonmatti
matti heino@Heinonmatti
Nassim, what's your take on Sornette's view of black swans?

They have a new paper that came out last week: "Multiple outlier detection in samples with exponential & Pareto tails" tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.10…

Image from wiki page: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dragon_ki…
Media image
@nntaleb
Nassim Nicholas Taleb@nntaleb
Bullshit. Straw man.
Actions
What You Can Do
  • Export as PDF or Markdown
  • Batch Export to Notion
  • Bookmark & Highlight
  • Screenshot Tweet
Create Free Account

Includes 7-day Premium trial

Advertisement