Remember Peloton? In 2023, Peloton's $2,500 bikes sold for $500 on...
Fernando Cao@thefernandocz
40 views
Apr 27, 2025
~3 min read
Advertisement
1
Remember Peloton?
In 2023, Peloton's $2,500 bikes sold for $500 on Facebook Marketplace.
They were losing $187M per quarter.
Then Peloton's CEO discovered ONE shocking truth about 21st-century humans...
Here's the mind-blowing insight that saved Peloton🧵
In 2023, Peloton's $2,500 bikes sold for $500 on Facebook Marketplace.
They were losing $187M per quarter.
Then Peloton's CEO discovered ONE shocking truth about 21st-century humans...
Here's the mind-blowing insight that saved Peloton🧵
2
During the pandemic, Peloton bikes were everywhere.
Peloton offered a complete at-home workout, and people were on waitlists for months to purchase the bikes.
Revenue shot to $4B in 2021 from $915M in 2019.
But eventually, people returned to gyms, creating a crisis at Peloton:
Peloton offered a complete at-home workout, and people were on waitlists for months to purchase the bikes.
Revenue shot to $4B in 2021 from $915M in 2019.
But eventually, people returned to gyms, creating a crisis at Peloton:
2:00
3
The demand for Peloton was vanishing—its stock plummeted 90%, and analysts predicted bankruptcy.
Customers were even selling their $2,500 bikes for $500 on Facebook Marketplace.
And it only got worse...
Customers were even selling their $2,500 bikes for $500 on Facebook Marketplace.
And it only got worse...
0:50
4
By late 2023, Peloton's numbers were brutal:
• Quarterly revenue was down by half from its peak
• Quarterly operating losses hit $187M
• Subscribers were down 16% YoY
That's when Peloton made a bold move...
• Quarterly revenue was down by half from its peak
• Quarterly operating losses hit $187M
• Subscribers were down 16% YoY
That's when Peloton made a bold move...
5
Peloton's new CEO, Barry McCarthy, completely rethought the company's strategy.
Unlike typical fitness CEOs, McCarthy had been CFO at Netflix and Spotify—companies that transformed entertainment through tech innovations.
And he spotted something at Peloton that everyone missed:
Unlike typical fitness CEOs, McCarthy had been CFO at Netflix and Spotify—companies that transformed entertainment through tech innovations.
And he spotted something at Peloton that everyone missed:
0:44
6
McCarthy realized the Peloton bike was actually just a ticket to join a community.
People weren't taking "cycling classes," they were riding with their favorite instructors.
So, he aimed to boost instructors' visibility on the platform and online.
But he faced pushback...
People weren't taking "cycling classes," they were riding with their favorite instructors.
So, he aimed to boost instructors' visibility on the platform and online.
But he faced pushback...
1:22
7
Investors worried about instructors leaving and taking their followers with them.
And analysts thought that influencers couldn't save a hardware company.
McCarthy was swimming against the current. But he trusted the data, not the conventional wisdom.
His strategy?
And analysts thought that influencers couldn't save a hardware company.
McCarthy was swimming against the current. But he trusted the data, not the conventional wisdom.
His strategy?
0:48
8
McCarthy's instructor-centric strategy was methodical:
• Encourage instructors to build personal brands on social media
• Create "tribes" around each instructor's style
• Redesign the app to highlight personalities
He challenged every industry norm.
The result?
• Encourage instructors to build personal brands on social media
• Create "tribes" around each instructor's style
• Redesign the app to highlight personalities
He challenged every industry norm.
The result?
9
Within two quarters, everything rebounded:
• Revenue jumped 20% to $743M
• Operating loss narrowed from $187M to $45M
• Positive free cash flow reached a new record at $106M
And it all happened because of one thing...
• Revenue jumped 20% to $743M
• Operating loss narrowed from $187M to $45M
• Positive free cash flow reached a new record at $106M
And it all happened because of one thing...
10
Communities. And they formed around each instructor.
One group created a book club centered on their instructor's favorite books, while another created charity fundraisers together.
McCarthy transformed Peloton from a product company into a relationship company.
The takeaway?
One group created a book club centered on their instructor's favorite books, while another created charity fundraisers together.
McCarthy transformed Peloton from a product company into a relationship company.
The takeaway?
0:48
11
Community builds more loyalty than any product feature.
When McCarthy repositioned instructors as brands, he created an emotional connection competitors couldn't match.
Personal brands became more important than the Peloton brand itself...
When McCarthy repositioned instructors as brands, he created an emotional connection competitors couldn't match.
Personal brands became more important than the Peloton brand itself...
1:10
12
This is 21st century business's most important insight:
The old ways of marketing are dead. Today, people crave connection, authenticity, and the human touch.
Think about it...
Mr Beast. Elon Musk. The Kardashians.
They're personal brands bigger than ANY company brand:
The old ways of marketing are dead. Today, people crave connection, authenticity, and the human touch.
Think about it...
Mr Beast. Elon Musk. The Kardashians.
They're personal brands bigger than ANY company brand:
13
People feel like they personally know them.
They've built trust with millions, and now, people will buy anything they make.
That's the power of a personal brand—create authentic content, and your reputation becomes your greatest asset.
Peloton took full advantage of this...
They've built trust with millions, and now, people will buy anything they make.
That's the power of a personal brand—create authentic content, and your reputation becomes your greatest asset.
Peloton took full advantage of this...
14
They knew personal brands would both attract AND keep customers.
Because today, people buy from people—not faceless corporations.
Become an authority in your niche, and EVERY business goal becomes 10x easier:
Sales. Investment. Hiring.
So:
Because today, people buy from people—not faceless corporations.
Become an authority in your niche, and EVERY business goal becomes 10x easier:
Sales. Investment. Hiring.
So:
0:44
