The stat that "72% of deaths in Gaza are combat-age men” is not...

Adar Weinreb@AdarWeinreb
7 views
May 04, 2025
~3 min read
Advertisement
1
The stat that "72% of deaths in Gaza are combat-age men” is not only not true, it’s very far from true.
Let’s dive in.
Where did this claim come from?
@Jerusalem_Post originally published this claim, but later quietly changed the headline from “72% of deaths are combat-age men” to “72% of combat-aged fatalities are men.
These are very different statements.
The article was updated, but the subheader still makes the original false claim. (photo below)
Exploring these claims
Debunking Claim #01: “72% of deaths in Gaza are combat-age men”
From the available data, 67% of those killed are male (including children and elderly).
Only 47% of total deaths fall into the so-called "combat-age males" bracket. Very far from 72%.
Debunking claim #02: “72% of combat-age fatalities are men”
The updated claim that of all of “combat ages 72% are men” is technically true, but when we look at what this actually means, it's not something to be proud of; it’s, in fact, very bad.
The way these reports define "combat age" is any male between the ages of 13-55.
For now, we’ll put aside the fact that the data clearly shows a negligible number of combatants between 13-17 (another thread on this later), we’ll be extremely charitable towards those making this claim and assume that this is in fact “combat age”.
If 50% of that age group were men, that would suggest that there are no combatants, as they'd be equally represented for their share of the population.
So, what does it mean that 72% are males?
It means that there are 15,048 excess male deaths in that age bracket, or roughly 30% of the total deaths.
So those claiming that “72% of combat-aged fatalities are men” are actually admitting that at least 70% of those killed have been civilians.
But in reality, it's likely far higher.
When we look at patterns from other violent conflicts, we see a consistent trend: civilian men are disproportionately killed. Not because they’re fighters, but because they’re suspected of being fighters.
Men are more likely to be seen as threats, more likely to leave shelter in search of food, water, or medicine, and more likely to work in dangerous roles like aid workers or first responders.
We see this trend hold true with males of all ages in Gaza.
Boys ages 10-13 are being killed at a 25% higher rate than girls of the same age.
Men aged 65-69 are being killed at a 74% higher rate than women of the same age.
Crunching the numbers:
If we're to assume civilian men are being killed at a rate of anywhere from 1.5x - 2.2x higher than women, then the list comprises anywhere from 20% - 8% combatants.
No matter how you spin it, no matter how charitable you want to be, there’s no world where the number 72% is in any way relevant to get an understanding of the situation in Gaza.
Those making claim #01 are spreading very easy to disprove misinformation. Those making claim #02 are acknowledging that the civilian-to-combatant ratio in Gaza is likely the highest in recent history.
This isn’t just misinformation. It’s propaganda, designed to manufacture public support for a war that has already taken a catastrophic civilian toll.
Misinformation is always bad.
This kind is deadly.
Let’s dive in.
Where did this claim come from?
@Jerusalem_Post originally published this claim, but later quietly changed the headline from “72% of deaths are combat-age men” to “72% of combat-aged fatalities are men.
These are very different statements.
The article was updated, but the subheader still makes the original false claim. (photo below)
Exploring these claims
Debunking Claim #01: “72% of deaths in Gaza are combat-age men”
From the available data, 67% of those killed are male (including children and elderly).
Only 47% of total deaths fall into the so-called "combat-age males" bracket. Very far from 72%.
Debunking claim #02: “72% of combat-age fatalities are men”
The updated claim that of all of “combat ages 72% are men” is technically true, but when we look at what this actually means, it's not something to be proud of; it’s, in fact, very bad.
The way these reports define "combat age" is any male between the ages of 13-55.
For now, we’ll put aside the fact that the data clearly shows a negligible number of combatants between 13-17 (another thread on this later), we’ll be extremely charitable towards those making this claim and assume that this is in fact “combat age”.
If 50% of that age group were men, that would suggest that there are no combatants, as they'd be equally represented for their share of the population.
So, what does it mean that 72% are males?
It means that there are 15,048 excess male deaths in that age bracket, or roughly 30% of the total deaths.
So those claiming that “72% of combat-aged fatalities are men” are actually admitting that at least 70% of those killed have been civilians.
But in reality, it's likely far higher.
When we look at patterns from other violent conflicts, we see a consistent trend: civilian men are disproportionately killed. Not because they’re fighters, but because they’re suspected of being fighters.
Men are more likely to be seen as threats, more likely to leave shelter in search of food, water, or medicine, and more likely to work in dangerous roles like aid workers or first responders.
We see this trend hold true with males of all ages in Gaza.
Boys ages 10-13 are being killed at a 25% higher rate than girls of the same age.
Men aged 65-69 are being killed at a 74% higher rate than women of the same age.
Crunching the numbers:
If we're to assume civilian men are being killed at a rate of anywhere from 1.5x - 2.2x higher than women, then the list comprises anywhere from 20% - 8% combatants.
No matter how you spin it, no matter how charitable you want to be, there’s no world where the number 72% is in any way relevant to get an understanding of the situation in Gaza.
Those making claim #01 are spreading very easy to disprove misinformation. Those making claim #02 are acknowledging that the civilian-to-combatant ratio in Gaza is likely the highest in recent history.
This isn’t just misinformation. It’s propaganda, designed to manufacture public support for a war that has already taken a catastrophic civilian toll.
Misinformation is always bad.
This kind is deadly.
