Deal by deal private equity (aka Independent Sponsor) is NOT for...

@PseudonymBear
No Name GP@PseudonymBear
11 views Mar 04, 2025 ~8 min read
Advertisement
1
Deal by deal private equity (aka Independent Sponsor) is NOT for the faint of heart. Here’s a breakdown on what it looks w/real data from our active process for a ~$20MM deal.

BUCKLE UP for: getting told “NO” ~100 times and watching your network EVAPORATE…oh and while that’s happening, you’re accruing diligence fees ($10k -> $50k -> $100k++) and just praying you can keep it all together.

🧵👇
2
For context, the company is ~$4mm of EBITDA, we're paying a reasonable entry multiple (read ~5x), there's a good chunk of seller rollover, and seller is staying on as CEO (he’s young and highly backable as far as LMM CEOs go).

(/2)
3
Business is in a stable sector (niche manufacturing) and we have a good reason to be the sponsor.

(/3)
4
Also, the structure has downside protection for new equity (1x liq. pref. over seller rollover). This was a key negotiating point for us with it being our first deal under our current IS banner as we knew it would help with the capital raise (which is still VERY tough).

(/4)
5
This means new investors have an entry multiple that is effectively sub-4x in a downside case.

(/5)
6
Okay, so we’ve got the deal dynamics out of the way, let’s get to the point – how do you raise the capital? We need about 6mm of third-party debt and 6mm of third-party equity (remember the seller is rolling a lot, so that helps reduce the 3rd party capital need).

We don’t like to over-lever these deals. Cap stack is ~40% debt / ~60% equity.

(/6)
7
And before anyone says SBA, please stop. This deal is too big to be an SBA-deal and PGs are out of the question with institutions on the cap table.

(/7)
8
Let’s start from the top of the funnel.

We’ve done deal-by-deal PE before, so we have a list of ~600 groups that we start with (took years to build). This includes institutions, family offices, etc. Both equity and debt investors. Shoutout @Attio (our CRM).

(/8)
9
This list includes folks we’ve worked w/in the past (we tag these as “red hot”), some we know / have met / have been referred to (“warm”) and some were cold outreach or folks we’d lost touch with over the years but still thought could be interested in the deal (“cold”).

(/9)
10
For this deal, we took that list of ~600 and selected ~120 groups to reach out. Of that 120, 10 of those groups were “red hot”, 32 were “warm” (~42 combined) and 78 were “cold” (~65% of the total mix).

(/10)
11
Yes, 78 is a lot of cold shots. But here’s the truth, until you are @jishbia or @BigJohn043 and have a track record, you’re going to need some cold shots to get the capital raised. It’s a numbers game…you’ll see why in a second.

(/11)
12
Also, we’re an IS, so we don’t have an investor relations team. You can only spend so much time cultivating relationships with capital partners, sourcing new deals, underwriting, convincing the seller to sell, getting the LOI, etc. etc.

(/12)
13
Our primary method for contact is email. We initially send teaser (outlines the deal, valuation, biz profile, etc.) + NDA.

A lot of people, even folks you know, won’t respond after email #1, so our “rule” is 3 emails; if we get ghosted after that, we stop bothering folks.

(/13)
14
So now we’ve got to send 120 initial emails. If you make this too “spammy” it’s just not a good look, so we try our best to personalize where appropriate. Yes there are tools to help with this, but we do it manually and it takes time (i.e. 1-2 days).

(/14)
15
We don’t want to annoy people, so we wait ~3-5 biz days in btw. emails. While that’s happening, the seller and broker are pressuring us for updates. We’re also managing QOE, insurance, tax, enviro, etc. workstreams in the background.

Hope you’re good at multi-tasking.

(/15)
16
Here’s what one of our days actually looked like:

7 – 8a: Send follow up emails to check-in with folks, answer a few DD questions.

8 – 9a: drive to company facility for meeting with seller
(we are still negotiating some points; always continuing our diligence)

9 – 12p: meeting with seller. Mid-way thru broker calls my phone 2x. Wants to know when we’re sending a first draft of the purchase agreement (this is the 3rd time he has asked in 2 weeks)…meanwhile the QOE is just now getting wrapped up.

End of meeting, Seller also drops a bomb that he’s starting to get cold feet about giving up control.

12 – 1p: drive back home, take call with potential capital partner on drive home. Cap partner starts asking detailed questions that I can’t recall off the top of my head. What fun.

1p – 2p: Return broker’s voicemail. Tell him purchase agreement won’t be worth anything until our other 3rd party work is done.

2p – 3p: call with QOE vendor to walk through some updates. Seller calls me while this happening.

3p – 4p: call seller back, he wants to re-negotiate his salary / bonus plan (which was already agreed to in the LOI).

4p – 6p: more emails, another call with a cap partner, tee up insurance and benefits provider.

6:30p: wife gets home from work; hang with her, walk to clear head.

7:30p – 11p: Start reading unreal emails from the day.

Realize that during the day we got another 6 people passing on the deal.

Contemplate life, eat some food, more admin work

BED, wake up and do it again tomorrow.

(/16)
17
Some people will get the first email and pass immediately, before signing an NDA, we call this “pass – pre-NDA”. Most of the time they don’t even tell you why they are passing, which is ironic, because their entire mandate is to invest in the type of deals we’re sharing.

(/17)
18
On this deal, we had 29 pre-NDA passes, and it took us 46 emails to work these people through the funnel. That’s 1.5 emails / on average per pass.

As expected, 20 of these were from cold shots.

So now we’ve already lost nearly 25% of our starting number.
91 groups remain…

(/18)
19
Here’s where it gets fun (or fun-LESS). A lot of people will ghost you, even after multiple follow-ups. We’ve had 46 people ghost us so far on this deal – we’ve collectively sent this group 100 emails.

>2 emails per group just for no feedback. Lost in oblivion.

Hope your feelings don’t get hurt easily.

(/19)
20
There will also be a few groups that turn the NDA with bad intentions (they just want to see our memo) and then will pass for no good reason (usually they blame it on “bad timing”).

We lost 4 groups that way.

(/20)
21
Alright. For those still with us. Summarizing so far:

+ 120 (top of funnel)
– 29 (pre-NDA passes)
– 46 (ghosted us)
– 4 (bad timing)
= 41 remaining

Now you see why I said it’s a numbers game.

That’s 34% conversion from top of funnel to STEP 1 (ie a call with us).

OR just take whatever # you start with and subtract about 2/3rd. So if you have 100 groups, assume only 33 will TURN the NDA. Forget about digging in. That’s just so you have a small chance to get them to see why you like the deal.

(/21)
22
STRAP IN.

Now the actual cap raising is about to start. We’ve got 41 groups that have turned the NDA and are reviewing our memo. Now we need to schedule calls with all these folks to give them the pitch.

(/22)
23
41 groups
30 – 60 min calls
~20 – 40+ hours of having the same meeting over and over.

Who are you, how’d you source the deal, why do you like it, what’s the thesis, etc., etc.

Of course all of these questions are answered in our memo, but that’s just how this game works.

(/23)
24
Now a number will drop after this stage. They took time for the call to ask these questions, but turns out they don’t like the deal.

They’ll pass for various reasons – doesn’t hit return thresholds, don’t believe in the growth story, we’re actually out of dry powder, etc.

(/24)
25
We had 19 drop after the memo review.

So we’ve got 22 groups left.

Just like that we’ve gone from 120 à 22.

That’s getting told “NO” from 98 people.

You want to be an indy sponsor, right?

(/25)
26
That gets us to today.

Of the 22, a good chunk are SBICs / junior capital folks that primary play in the debt. So checks that are 60% debt / 40% equity, at best. Very few 50-50 equity/debt guys out there.

So even if 1 comes through, we’ve still got an equity gap.

(/26)
27
And that’s a wrap…for now.

We’ve sent 300+ emails.
Had 40+ hours of meetings.
And we’ve got ~$2mm of equity soft-circled.
Still waiting on a term sheet from an anchor.

Welcome to Independent Sponsor fundraising.

Oh... and as I'm writing this, we've gotten 3 more passes. Not even 2pm yet.

🧢tip @OneManLBO + @FunlessSponsor for inspiration.

(/end)
Actions
What You Can Do
  • Export as PDF or Markdown
  • Batch Export to Notion
  • Bookmark & Highlight
  • Screenshot Tweet
Create Free Account

Includes 7-day Premium trial

Advertisement