Worthwhile watching the whole thing, with the initial 40 minutes of...

@MarcoCantamessa
Marco Cantamessa@MarcoCantamessa
5 views Mar 01, 2025 ~3 min read
Advertisement
1
Worthwhile watching the whole thing, with the initial 40 minutes of apparent agreement being followed by the final breakdown.
Was it a planned ambush? Was it an incident, caused by soured relationships between Zelensky and Vance?
Either way…
49:53
2
…allowing this to happen in public, repeatedly dismissing Zelensky’s legitimate concerns about security, keeping a negotiating line and a narrative that is closer to Russia than to Ukraine and - finally - bullying, scolding and threatening the leader of a nation…
3
… fighting a war against an aggressor, is a stain on American leadership that will last for decades.
4
Addendum.
Let’s suppose for a moment that the position of the US administration is genuine, and not driven by some kind of backdoor deal, or commonality in feelings with Russia (something I would not rule out).
1/
5
The whole scene makes it clear that the current US administration is not inspired by any values.
To them, it’s irrelevant to discern between aggressor and aggressed, or whether someone is committing war crimes or not.
Ethical aspects aside, can this be effective?
2/
6
The only thing the WH seems to consider is force. If you are are aggressed and weak, surrender. If you are strong, why not aggress? If your resistance depends on my support, do what I tell you. Security guarantees are useless, since I’m strong and that’s enough.
3/
7
You might think that this stems from the fact that Trump and Vance views politics as dealmaking (Trump repeated this a lot of times during the conference).
4/
8
True, but his is also a shortsighted view of dealmaking, since it does not care to understand the motives and the utility functions of the parties involved.
Specifically, they do not understand that this deal is different from the perspectives of the US, Russia, and Ukraine.
5/
9
To the US (and also to Russia) this is just “one deal” of many. Their position is like the one of a real estate developer (like Trump) or venture capitalist (like Vance), living on a deal flow.
6/
10
Deals come and go, sometimes you win and sometimes you lose, and it is unreasonable to cling so dearly to a single deal where your bargaining position is weak.
7/
11
For the US, the objective in this “deal of many” is not to secure lasting peace, but to get a deal done quick, and the “vested interest in rare earths” being trumpeted by Vance is obviously not enough to secure their permanent commitment to guarantee lasting peace.
8/
12
To Ukraine, instead, this is “the deal”, the one and only deal that will determine their lives.
Their insistence on security guarantees is not due to arrogance or nitpicking. It’s that they know these are crucial.
9/
13
They are obviously afraid of losing support now, but this would be the same if - after a deal - guarantees would not be enforced.
They therefore have nothing to lose.
a) Fighting alone is best done now, than in a few years’ time, after Russia has rearmed.
10/
14
b) in their eyes, every square meter of land not being surrendered is a victory.
c) even if they lost the whole country, it would become an untenable Afghanistan for the Russians.

Why on earth should they settle for a quick deal, just for the sake of having one?
Actions
What You Can Do
  • Export as PDF or Markdown
  • Batch Export to Notion
  • Bookmark & Highlight
  • Screenshot Tweet
Create Free Account

Includes 7-day Premium trial

Advertisement