Montessori believed learning to read starting at 5+ was *too late*...

@_samantha_joy
Samantha Watkins@_samantha_joy
12 views Jun 29, 2024 ~5 min read
Advertisement
1
Montessori believed learning to read starting at 5+ was *too late*

In her schools, formal phonics instruction starts around 2.5 - 3yo

And reading preparation starts even earlier with younger toddlers...even babies.

But WHY??? (Hint: The reason isn't what you think)
2
Many hear 'toddlers learning to read' and get nervous.

They see a method for tiger moms and the rat race.

They see a pushy method, improperly focusing on cognitive goals.

Why steal childhoods, they think. Why not just let kids play?
3
And, to be fair, there *are* parents who co-opt the Montessori approach as the first step to getting their child into Harvard,

who *are* pushy and demanding.

who use it only to brag about little Johnny's abilities at the next gathering... or to anyone who will listen.
4
And even though it's likely true that early reading ability has profound benefits,

that it sets children up to dive deeply into content knowledge in elementary+,

and to be able to do so far more independently than the norm...

this is not the primary reason to do it.
5
The primary reason we, as Montessorians, teach very young children to read ... or scrub a table ... or put on their own coat ... is:

it makes them happy.
6
Not happy in the transient eating candy kind of way. Not even happy in the delightful, giggling, tickle war way.

But happy in a rich, enduring, proud sense.

The happiness of Michelangelo creating the David, Newton defining the laws of motion, Steve Jobs envisioning the iPhone.
7
Seem far-fetched?

One clue it's not is that, instead of picking up and putting down 20 toys in 20 minutes,

with evident restlessness, mounting threats of tantrums, or demands for parent entertainment, as is typical of a child who is 2.5 or 3...
8
a Montessori child:

> *chooses* to do real, challenging work
> focuses on it for a half hour, an hour, maybe more at a time
> prefers to work alone, without 'entertainment', praise, or distraction

By every measure, the child appears deeply satisfied and self-sufficient.
9
Seeing this in action is a revelation for many parents & teachers.

For others, it arouses still more suspicion. There must be some trick behind it, they think.

Montessori teachers must be stifling the child's spirit, perhaps manipulating them with threats or treats...
10
After all, work is something to endure, get over with, to do because you must to get the things you *really* want, right?

Maaaaybe you can sugarcoat work with 'fun' but a child that *chooses* work with little embellishment? That implies corruption or trickery, doesn't it?
11
This attitude often says more about them than it does Montessori.

Often, it tragically means that they never had the opportunity for fulfilling work as a child—and now resent their job, live for the evenings and weekends, and long for early retirement...
12
But this isn't always the reason for suspicion.

An adult may love their own work, look forward to Monday, even joyfully fit in some work on weekends,

but think that childhood happiness is different, that it means playing tag, getting presents, and eating ice cream... not work
13
Theirs is a failure of imagination.

As pleasurable as treats, gifts, or games truly are, they are no more the substantive makeup of childhood happiness, than a diet of gummy bears would be for their health.
14
A young child is wholly new, not only to the world at large, but to every single human faculty.

The same delight a child has in discovering a ladybug or the moon or a pretty pebble, is possible in discovering that they can read, write, or add numbers.
15
If you woke up tomorrow with the ability to fly... *if only* you practiced,

If you were suddenly transported to the world of Harry Potter and could use magic ... *if only* you studied,

would watching movies or scrolling tik tok have any draw for you in that moment?
16
Or would you be like Peter Parker in Spiderman,

when he spent hours, perhaps days or weeks, lost in focus learning to climb walls, shoot webs, and swing from building to building?
17
Learning to read, for a 3yo, has the same glamor as superpowers or magic would have for us.

It *is* an increase of power.

For a child, learning to read means having access to a tremendously sophisticated way to navigate and understand her world.
18
So much of a young child's world is inaccessible or incomprehensible to her.

She cannot reach things, or things are forbidden her.

She does not know the names for so much of what she sees; she does not understand much of what adults are saying around her.
19
But when she learns to read?

Suddenly, a whole new facet of the world is open to her. As she goes about life, so much becomes fresh and is seen again with new eyes.

... because there's writing everywhere.
20
Not only in storybooks, but on road signs, at grocery stores, in decorative art in her own home.

Everywhere she looks, what once was just visual noise in a chaotic environment, she discovers order, structure, and a challenge she can surmount using her new powers.
21
Asking "Why teach a 3yo to read now when they can learn just fine later on?"

is like asking:

"Why be happy today, when you could be happy at 50yo and still have half a century left?"
22
Happiness, ability, fulfillment, self-esteem... are their own justifications.

No, Montessori doesn't design her educational approach for "whatever gives a child pleasure."

But it is designed to unlock work, learning, *human life and growth* as the *highest* pleasure.
Actions
What You Can Do
  • Export as PDF or Markdown
  • Batch Export to Notion
  • Bookmark & Highlight
  • Screenshot Tweet
Create Free Account

Includes 7-day Premium trial

Advertisement