This is a bizarre but incredibly important interaction for...

Advertisement
1
This is a bizarre but incredibly important interaction for understanding how JK Rowling's mind works post-radicalisation, and how cult movements and extremist groups are able to function in conflict with seemingly undeniable reality.

A small thread 🧵
Media image
2
... Rowling makes a post suggesting that the Nazi attack on Institut für Sexualwissenschaft was "a fever dream" without a "source"

Alejandra Caraballo responds by giving sources. It's a well documented historical event. Sources are easy to find.

And then things get weirder...
Media image
3
... JK Rowling suggests those sources don't actually count because they don't prove "all research on trans healthcare was burned" or "trans people were the first victims of the Nazis".

Well yeah. They don't claim that.

The tweet Rowling called a fever dream didn't claim that...
Media image
4
... What's happened here is that JK Rowling has public tweeted out something that's not just bigoted, revolting, historical revisionism. It's also very, very stupid.

And it's *obviously* stupid.

Ten seconds of Googling would have proved her wrong and she couldn't be bothered...
Media image
5
... But JK Rowling has spent the last half decade essentially being worshipped by a cult.

She is used to stating obvious nonsense without pushback. To anti-LGBTQ+ campaigners, she is infallible. They will change their perception of reality to match whatever she proclaims...
Media image
6
... So when she absolutely puts her foot in her mouth, her ego does not have the capacity to admit "Oh shit, we have said something painfully idiotic and easy to disprove here"

Instead, she tries the method that works with the cult.

Simply deny reality and substitute her own...
Media image
7
... Now, this is what's known as a Motte-and-Bailey Fallacy. Or you could consider it a Straw Man Fallacy.

Or you could just call it lying.

But the important part isn't really the weak deception as it is the fact that JK Rowling is just openly doing this BS in public...
Media image
8
... Rather than accepting that she was - objectively - wrong, JK Rowling tries to retcon reality.

Like a small child without object permanence.

And when she's called out on it, she finds an *entirely different tweet* and tries to slot it in the place of the one she attacked...
Media image
Media image
9
... It's bizarre.

It's genuinely uncomfortable to watch someone with such a lose grip on factual reality. Someone who has become so used to her worshippers that she truly expects all of humanity to ignore when she's been caught out and make-believe that she's right, actually...
Media image
10
... To be clear, this WILL of course still work on her cultists.

Even now there are doubtless "Gender Critical" journalists trying to work out how to contort the facts to make JK Rowling sound like she hasn't denied historically evidenced Nazi atrocities. It's what cults do...
Media image
Media image
11
... But it should be fairly clear to anyone who is not actively trying to delude themselves that JK Rowling is completely full of bovine manure.

She clings to self-imposed ignorance. She has no time for evidence, or indeed anything that conflicts with her extreme worldview...
Media image
12
... Now, interestingly, JK Rowling tries to pivot again.

She's trying to overrule the work of historians and holocaust researchers by citing Malcolm Clark, a non-historian who has attacked having LGBTQ+ groups in schools and has worked with the transphobic LGB Alliance.

BUT...
Media image
13
...If you take a few seconds to look at it properly you can see she's doing the exact same thing again

Her first tweet was specifically about denying the looting of the Institut für Sexualwissenschaft. She cannot defend that position so she tries to substitute a different one...
Media image
Media image
14
... Also, side note:

There is one hell of an irony to pointing out that someone who worked for the institute saved their own skin by betraying LGBTQ+ people and collaborating with the Nazis...

... while being a "Pick Me!" gay man collaborating with JK freaking Rowling.
Media image
Actions
What You Can Do
  • Export as PDF or Markdown
  • Batch Export to Notion
  • Bookmark & Highlight
  • Screenshot Tweet
Create Free Account

Includes 7-day Premium trial

Advertisement