1/N This is a thread on how ancient Indians pioneered the field of...

@selfvision
Self Vision@selfvision
15 views Mar 16, 2026 ~16 min read
Advertisement
1
1/N
This is a thread on how ancient Indians pioneered the field of large numbers & fast-growing functions - what is today known as Googology.
Media image
2
2/N
For our journey into ancient India’s discovery of large numbers, we will look into multiple schools of thoughts including Vedic, Jaina & Buddhist.
3
3/N
Before we delve into the topics, it’s important to talk a bit more about the scope of the topic.
4
4/N
Disclaimer 1: The extent of work available on the topic of large numbers from ancient Indian literature is vast. I will only address a fairly limited aspect of the foundation of large numbers in this thread.
5
5/N
Disclaimer 2: The ancient Indians delved deeply into the notion of infinity as well. While this is very related to the concept of large numbers, infinity in the Indic context is a separate topic by itself. So I will not talk about infinity in this thread.
6
6/N
Disclaimer 3: To keep the material accessible, I have avoided use of modern googological notations such as “Knuth’s up-arrow notation”, “Conway chained arrow notation” etc in representing the large numbers
7
7/N
With the above important disclaimers out of the way, we are now ready for the main topic.
8
8/N
First we will look into the application of large numbers in Vedas. But before we do that, we will take a brief detour and try to understand the role of large numbers in the context of Vedic rituals.
Media image
9
9/N
Yajna (यज्ञ) or fire based ritual is a very important aspect of Vedic way of life where the primary goal is self-realization
10
10/N
Yajna (यज्ञ) in its essence represents any action or work done, inner or outer, with an attitude of surrender and offering to the superconsciousness (ब्रह्मन्) - embodiment of Truth (ऋतम्)
11
11/N
Yajman (यजमान) in this context is the individual whose aspiration is to go through the transformative process of self-realization
12
12/N
One of the primary offerings made to fire in Yajna is Ghrita (घृत) or clarified butter. Ghrta in this context symbolizes an illumined mind, purified with the light of intuition, golden in hue.
13
13/N
Agni (अग्नि) is fire, the ultimate transformative agent. It symbolizes the divine Will that takes up the action in all consecration of works. Agni is a flame of force instinct with the light of divine knowledge. Agni is the seer-will in the universe unerring in all its works
14
14/N
The ground where this fire ritual is done is called Vedi (वेदी). It represents an individual with such a mind whose foundation has been prepared with pre-requisite knowledge of self realization (विद्या)
15
15/N
The Shulba Sutras provide detailed instructions for how to perform Yajna or fire based rituals including construction of the चिति (Chiti) or altar - which requires detailed understanding of structural engineering in three dimensions.
16
16/N
Chiti (चिति) represents the core of consciousness (चित्त / Chitta) where the transformation from all layers of the being takes place with the help of Agni.
17
17/N
The construction of the altar requires careful selection of different sizes of bricks called इष्टका (Ishtaka) in Sanskrit. These bricks need to carefully used to satisfy a set of geometrical constraints to form the 3D altar
18
18/N
These इष्टका or bricks represent the great resolution & will power of the individual (यजमान) who is willing to sacrifice those aspects of her being where the light of consciousness has not reached yet
19
19/N
The end-products of the Yajna are Gau (cows) & Ashva (horses) which represent two companion ideas of Light (गौ) and Energy (अश्व) - the twin aspect of all the activities of existence. They are symbolic of the richness of mental illumination & abundance of pure vital energy.
20
20/N
Now, we are ready to see why large numbers were used in Vedic rituals.
21
21/N
In Shukla Yajurveda 17.2, we find a Mantra where the individual who is an aspirant of self-realization is wishing how both the material of the Yajna and the ultimate fruit in abundance would help in his transformative journey.
Media image
22
22/N
Notice, how large numbers have been used to “quantify” mental & vital abundance. Below I am providing a rough translation of Shukla Yajurveda 17.2
23
23/N
Translation of Shukla Yajurveda 17.2 is given below
Media image
24
24/N
Notice how the numbers have been named in the Shukla Yajurveda 17.2 Mantra: starting from Eka (one) to Parardha (10^18 - ten raised to the power of 18). I am summarizing the large numbers mentioned in Yajurveda here
Media image
25
25/N
The Vedas are so ancient that they are hard to date. Traditionally they are considered “Apaurusheya'' or texts that are revealed to self-realized Rishis
26
26/N
According to some researchers archeo-astronomy evidence exists to show that the earliest Vedic hymns were written before 22,000 BCE !
27
27/N
It is simply mind-boggling to think that numbers as large as Parardha (10^18) were known to ancient Indians possibly by 22,000 BCE
28
28/N
Now, we are going to look at the great Indian epic Ramayana to continue our journey of large numbers
Media image
29
29/N
In Ramayana Yuddha Kanda, we find शुक (Shuka), one of the administrative chiefs of the mighty & scholarly King Ravana, was commissioned to collect information about the army of Bhagavan Ramachandra, an Avatara and the magnificent prince of Ayodhya from Ikshvaku dynasty.
30
30/N
In this context, शुक gives a description of large numbers. He says “It is said by wise men that hundred thousand crores multiplied by hundred thousand crores as referred to as Shanku”
31
31/N
Shanku as described in Ramayana is one trillion - 10 raised to the power of 12 or 10^12
Media image
32
32/N
Shuka (शुक) in Ramayana then continues to define even larger numbers. He uses Shatam Sahasram & Shanku as the basis to describe increasingly larger numbers. Here we see the early application of building large numbers using a fast growing function
33
33/N
In this case, we see Shuka in Ramayana building up to the number Maha Augha, which is 10 raised to the power of 60 (10^60)
Media image
34
34/N
I am summarizing Shuka’s description from Ramayana in a tabular format below
Media image
35
35/N
Ravana’s minister Shuka then sums up the unimaginable strength of Rama’s army of Vaanara sena in a very quantifiable manner.
Media image
36
36/N
So, from Shuka’s description, we can assess that the equivalent strength of Rama’s army can be computed as given below. Notice that Shuka is talking about the effective strength of the army - not the number of soldiers.
Media image
37
38/N
Dr. P V Vartak proposed 4 December 7324 BCE as the day of Rama-Janma. Nilesh Oak gives a date of 12200 BCE primarily based on archeo-astronomy.
38
39/N
Essentially very large numbers such as Maha Augha (10^60) were already in common parlance by at least 7400 BCE in India.
39
40/N
Next we will focus on Jaina literature to understand the concept of Vargita-samvargita: a process to generate very large numbers using an iterative method.
Media image
40
41/N
A detailed description of Vargita-samvargita is found in the Ṣaṭkhandagama, which is the foremost and oldest Digambara Jain sacred text. Ṣaṭkhandagama is dated to be compiled no later than 200 CE
41
42/N
Acharya Virasena was a brilliant mathematician. He was also proficient in astronomy, grammar, logic, mathematics and prosody.
42
43/N
Virasena wrote a 72,000 shloka commentary on Shatkhandagama (known as Dhavala and the last section called Mahadhavala). Dhavala is dated to be composed no later than 9th century CE
43
44/N
Virasena mentions the process of Vargita-samvargita in Dhavala Part 3
Media image
44
45/N
A description of the Vargita-samvargita process using modern notation is provided below
Media image
45
46/N
Before we delve into specific large numbers in Jaina mathematics, let’s do a quick survey of the ontology of the number system itself from a Jaina perspective.
46
47/N
We are going to refer to the brilliant Jain text Anuyogadwara Sutra dated no later than 100 BCE.
47
48/N
Ganana Samkhya (samkhya as counting) is as follows
1. Samkhyat (countable)
2. Asamkhyat (innumerable)
3. Anant (infinite)
Media image
48
49/N
Samkhyat (countable) is of three kinds
1. Jaghanya Samkhyat (countable min)
2. Utkrishta Samkhyat (countable max)
3. Ajaghanya-Anutkrisht Samkhyat (countable intermediate)
Media image
49
50/N
Asamkhyat (innumerable) is of three kinds
1. Parit Asamkhyat (lower innumerable)
2. Yukta Asamkhyat (innumerable raised to the power of itself)
3. Asamkhyat Asamkhyat (innumerable-innumerable)
Media image
50
51/N
Parit Asamkhyat (lower innumerable) is of three kinds
1. Jaghanya Parit Asamkhyat (minimum lower innumerable)
2. Utkrisht Parit Asamkhyat (maximum lower innumerable)
3. Ajaghanyaauthkrish Parit Asamkhyat (intermediate lower innumerable)
Media image
51
52/N
Yukta Asamkhyat is of 3 kinds
1. Jaghanya Yukt Asamkhyat (innumerable raised to the power of itself, min)
2. Utkrisht Yukt Asamkhyat (innumerable raised to the power of itself, max)
3. Ajaghanya-Anutkrisht Yukt Asamkhyat (innumerable raised to power of itself, intermediate)
Media image
52
53/N
Asamkhyat-Asamkhyat is of 3 kinds

1. Jaghanya Asamkhyat-Asamkhyat (min innumerable-innumerable)
2. Utkrisht Asamkhyat-Asamkhyat (max innumerable-innumerable)
3. Ajaghanya-Anutkrisht Asamkhyat-Asamkhyat (intermediate innumerable-innumerable)
Media image
53
54/N
Ananta (infinite) is of three kinds:
1. Parit Ananta (lower infinite)
2. Yukt Ananta (infinite raised to power of itself)
3. Ananta Ananta (infinite-infinite)
Media image
54
55/N
Parit Ananta is of three kinds

1. Jaghanya Parit Ananta (min lower infinite)
2. Utkrisht Parit Ananta (max lower infinite)
3. Ajaghanya-Anutkrisht Parit Ananta (intermediate lower infinite)
Media image
55
56/N
Yukta Ananta is of three kinds

1. Jaghanya Yukta Ananta (min lower infinite)
2. Utkrisht Yukta Ananta (max lower infinite)
3. Ajaghanya-Anutkrisht Yukta Ananta (intermediate lower infinite)
Media image
56
57/N
Ananta Ananta is of three kinds
1. Jaghanya Ananta Ananta (min infinite infinite)
2. Utkrisht Ananta Ananta (max infinite infinite)
3. Ajaghanya-Anutkrisht Ananta Ananta (intermediate infinite infinite)
Media image
57
58/N
We are going to focus on the number Jaghanya Parita Asaṃkhyata which is the smallest nearly innumerable number and the largest numerable number.
58
59/N
There is a precise definition for the number Jaghanya Parita Asaṃkhyata. To understand that we need to have a primer on Jaina cosmology.
59
60/N
According to Jain cosmology, Jambudweepa (Jambu island) is at the center of Madhyaloka, or the middle part of the universe
60
61/N
Jambūdvīpaprajñapti contains a description of Jambūdvīpa and life biographies of Rishabha and King Bharata.
61
62/N
Trilokasāra, Trilokaprajñapti, Trilokadipikā and Kṣetrasamāsa are the other texts that provide the details of Jambūdvīpa and Jaina cosmology.
62
63/N
The middle world consists of a central island, which is surrounded by alternating annular oceans and islands.
63
64/N
The central circular island called Jambudwīpa is surrounded by an annular ocean called Lavaṇa Ocean.
64
65/N
An annular island called Dhātakīkhaṇḍa surrounds the Lavaṇa Ocean.
65
66/N
Dhātakīkhaṇḍa is surrounded by an annular ocean called Kālodadhi, which is again surrounded by an island called Puṣkaravara.
66
67/N
This pattern continues till the edge of the universe. The number of these concentric islands and oceans is extremely large.
67
68/N
The definition of jaghanya-parita-asamkhyata is linked to this cosmology. First we setup the problem with formal notation with the help of a diagram
Media image
68
69/N
Formal definition of the googlogical number Jaghanya Parita Asaṃkhyata is given here
Media image
69
70/N
Finally the formal definition of Jaghanya Parita Asaṃkhyata is given here
Media image
70
71/N
Here we show how to find the value of n_0
Media image
71
72/N
Analysis of how to find the value of n_0 continues here
Media image
72
73/N
Here it is shown how to find the value of n_0 as found in Trilokasara
Media image
73
74/N
Trilokasara Gatha 17
Media image
74
75/N
Trilokasara Gatha 18
Media image
75
76/N
Trilokasara Gatha 21
Media image
76
77/N
Trilokasara Gatha 22
Media image
77
78/N
Trilokasara Gatha 28
(Note the value here. This is what we derived earlier)
Media image
78
79/N
It is important to note that the rules in Trilokasara gatha 22 and Trilokasara gatha 23 are very similar to what was already given by Brahmagupta in his Brahmasphuta-Siddhanta which was composed earlier than Trilokasara gatha
Media image
79
80/N
There is a very interesting and intricate counting mechanism which leads to the unfathomably large number jaghanya-parita-asamkhyata
Media image
80
81/N
The description of the iterative counting method to find jaghanya-parita-asamkhyata
continues
Media image
81
82/N
As will be seen below, the number jaghanya-parita-asamkhyata is very large. We will find a tight lower bound for its value.
82
83/N
However, before we can find a lower value, we need to find a recursive relation between n_(i+1) and n_(i) using the principle of vargita-samvargita discussed earlier.
83
84/N
Here we find a general expression of n and r first
Media image
84
85/N
Here we find a cool relationship between n_(i+1) and n_(i) using the principle of vargita-samvargita - which will come handy next to find a lower bound of jaghanya-parita-asamkhyata
Media image
85
86/N
Finally, we are ready to assess a lower-bound of the humongous number jaghanya-parita-asamkhyata.
Media image
86
87/N
Now we will discuss the large numbers in Lalitavistara Sūtra, a prominent Buddhist text (no later than 300 CE)
Media image
87
88/N
The Lalitavistara Sūtra is a Sanskrit Mahayana Buddhist sutra that tells the story of Gautama Buddha from the time of his descent from Tushita until his first sermon at Sarnath near Varanasi.
88
89/N
In the 12th chapter of Lalitavistara Sutra (शिल्पसंदर्शनपरिवर्तः), we find that grand preparation for selecting a bridegroom for the Prince Sarvarthasiddha (Buddha) was ongoing in Kapilavastu.
89
90/N
Here is the reference from 12th chapter of Lalitavistara Sutra
Media image
90
91/N
The reference from 12th chapter of Lalitavistara Sutra continues here
Media image
91
92/N
Prince Sarvarthasiddha (Buddha) did not want a regular princess to marry.
92
93/N
The prince wrote a collection of verses describing the desired qualities of the bride which included: knowledge of the Dharma, nobility of thoughts, elegance of appearance, prosperity of mind, expertise in public administration & public speech.
93
94/N
Gopa, daughter of Dandapani, from Kapilavastu was exquisitely beautiful & wise. She had all the qualities Sarvarthasiddha was looking for.
94
95/N
Shudhhodana, father of Sarvarthasiddha sent the marriage proposal for Gopa and his son to Dandapani, father of the future bride.
95
96/N
However Dandapani sent a message back saying “We have a family custom not to have our daughter married to someone who is not an expert in art such as swordsmanship, wrestling and topics of science such as mathematics & astronomy”
96
97/N
Given this condition from the bride’s family, a grand event was held, where five hundred Shakya princes were invited in a competition where prince Sarvarthasiddha could compete & demonstrate his expertise on topics of art and science.
97
98/N
In that grand competition, Sarvarthasiddha had to compete with a brilliant mathematician from Kapilavastu named Arjuna.
98
99/N
Arjuna asked Sarvarthasiddha, “Do you, Prince, know the order of reckoning after a Koti Shata (10 raised to the power of 9)” ?
99
110/N
Sarvarthasiddha showed off his skills in mathematics by citing the names of the powers of ten, up to “Tallakshana”, which equals to 10 raised to the power of 53.
100
101/N
Because the list of large numbers as mentioned in Lalitavistara Sūtra is pretty long, I have broken it up in parts. In the first part, Sarvarthasiddha (Buddha) goes from Ayuta (10 raised to the power of 9) to Hetuhila (10 raised to the power of 31)
Media image
101
102/N
Here Sarvarthasiddha (Buddha) goes from Karahu (10 raised to the power of 33) to Tallakshana (10 raised to the power of 53)
Media image
102
103/N
But Sarvarthasiddha did not stop there. He then explained how this series can be extended geometrically.
103
104/N
He starts from Dhvajagravati (10 raised to the power of 99). The last number at which he arrived at after going through seven successive steps was Paramanurajahpravesha (परमानुरजःप्रवेश), which is 10 raised to the power of 421
104
105/N
Below I am providing the rest of the table as mentioned in Lalitavistara Sutra
Media image
105
106/N
The very large ntity परमानुरजःप्रवेश (10 ^ 421) has been compared with the conceptual vastness of Tathagata Bodhisattva.
106
107/N
Next we we will to Buddhāvataṃsaka Sūtra, an important Mahāyāna Buddhist text for our exploration of large numbers.
Media image
107
108/N
Buddhāvataṃsaka Sūtra is one of the most influential Mahāyāna Buddhist sutras. It is also often referred to as the Avataṃsaka Sūtra. In Sanskrit, the term Avataṃsaka means “a great number,” “a multitude,” or “a collection.”
108
109/N
The original Buddhāvataṃsaka Sūtra was in Sanskrit, which was later translated to Tibetan & Chinese
109
110/N
According to Akira Hirakawa and Otake Susumu Sanskrit original of Buddhāvataṃsaka Sūtra, was compiled in India about 500 years after death of Gautama Buddha
110
111/N
In this text we will find how Buddha provides a fast growing function. The last number in the series is a called “Anabhilapyanabhilapya -Parivarta” which is 10 raised to the power of 37,218,383,881,977,700,000,000,000,000,000,000,000
111
112/N
In the 30th Book of the Buddhāvataṃsaka Sūtra (असंख्येय), we find a Bodhisattva asking the Buddha: “O Bhagavat, when expounding on the Dharma, the buddhas, the tathāgatas, use very large numbers”
112
113/N
Bodhisattva continues: “The tathāgatas use such numbers as ‘asaṃkhyeya,’ ‘measureless,’ ‘bound- less,’ ‘incomparable,’ ‘innumerable,’ ‘indescribable,’ ‘inconceivable,’ ‘incalculable,’ ‘ineffable.’ O Bhagavat, what is meant by ‘asaṃkhyeya’ and so forth?
113
114/N
The Buddha then goes into this amazing discourse of listing numbers in chronological order.
114
115/N
Buddha starts from Koti (10 raised to the power 7) and ends up this mind-bogglingly large umber “Anabhilapyanabhilapya-Parivarta” which is same as 10 raised to the power of 1,163,074,496,311,800,000,000,000,000,000,000,000
115
116/N
Because the list of these large numbers in Buddhāvataṃsaka Sūtra is long, I will break it up into multiple tables.
116
117/N
The following table from Buddhāvataṃsaka Sūtra starts from Koti (10 raised to the power of 7) and ends with Avaga (10 raised to the power of 28672).
Media image
117
118/N
The next table from Buddhāvataṃsaka Sūtra starts from Viturna (10 raised to the power of 7516192768) and ends with Kshamuda (10 raised to the power of 246290604621824).
Media image
118
119/N
The next table from Buddhāvataṃsaka Sūtra starts from Elada (10 raised to the power of 492581209243648) and ends with Hematra (10 raised to the power of 504,403,158,265,496,000).
Media image
119
120/N
The next table from Buddhāvataṃsaka Sūtra starts from Vematra (10 raised to the power of 1,008,806,316,530,990,000) and ends with Meruda (10 raised to the power of 16,528,282,690,043,800,000,000).
Media image
120
121/N
The next table from Buddhāvataṃsaka Sūtra starts from Kheluda (10 raised to the power of 33,056,565,380,087,500,000,000) and ends with Havava (10 raised to the power of 33,849,922,949,209,600,000,000,000).
Media image
121
122/N
The next table from Buddhāvataṃsaka Sūtra starts from Vivara (10 raised to the power of 67,699,845,898,419,200,000,000,000) and ends with Akshaya (10 raised to the power of 138,649,284,399,963,000,000,000,000,000)
Media image
122
123/N
The next table from Buddhāvataṃsaka Sūtra starts from Sambhuta (10 raised to the power of 277,298,568,799,925,000,000,000,000,000) and ends with Aparyanta (10 raised to the power of 1,135,814,937,804,490,000,000,000,000,000,000).
Media image
123
124/N
The final table from Buddhāvataṃsaka Sūtra starts from Aparyanta-Parivarta (10 raised to the power of 277,298,568,799,925,000,000,000,000,000) and ends with Anabhilapyanabhilapya
-Parivarta
124
125/N
Anabhilapyanabhilapya--Parivarta
is equivalent this mind-bogglingly HUGE number (10 raised to the power of 37,218,383,881,977,700,000,000,000,000,000,000,000).
Media image
125
126/N
In the European context, Archimedes, a Greek polymath, sometime in the 300 BCE started experimenting with large number in his book “Sand Reckoner”
126
127/N
Ancient Indians not only pioneered the study of large numbers at least 10000 years before Greeks (or any Europeans), but were using it in both mathematical work as well as in literature and poetry.
127
128/N
The study of large numbers invented in India is today known as googology. It is an important tool for understanding some of the fundamental principles of mathematics and for exploring the limits of what is currently known about the properties of large numbers
128
129/N
References
Media image
Actions
What You Can Do
  • Export as PDF or Markdown
  • Batch Export to Notion
  • Bookmark & Highlight
  • Screenshot Tweet
Create Free Account

Includes 7-day Premium trial

Advertisement