Why I left atheism, 12 part thread🪡🧵 As an atheist there were...

@darwintojesus
Darwin to Jesus@darwintojesus
12 views Sep 01, 2024 ~8 min read
Advertisement
1
Why I left atheism, 12 part thread🪡🧵

As an atheist there were always two things I truly cared about. The truth, and morality. The first thing that really got me asking serious questions about my atheism was the subject of morality, and it was caused by other atheists. 1/12🪡
2
One day I happened to be in a live chat with a bunch of atheists. I had told them I was an atheist and I said something along the lines of rape being wrong. The other atheists happened to know quite a bit about philosophy and told me that rape wasn’t actually wrong, only “subjectively” wrong, and that atheism couldn’t justify objective morality. 2/12🪡
3
I thought this was the most absurd thing I had ever heard. Rape was wrong, I knew that, everyone knew that! How could atheists say otherwise? They told me about Hume’s Guillotine, which shows that an Ought* cannot be derived from an Is.* For example, just because my house IS green, doesn’t in any way mean it OUGHT to be green, or purple, or any color. How a thing IS* has nothing to do with how it objectively SHOULD* be. So they told me this, and I set out to prove them wrong. 3/12🪡
4
I studied the subject of morality and Hume’s guillotine and tried for about FOUR years to justify objective morality within an atheist worldview. It simply cannot be done. Here is why… First you have to ground (provide a foundation in reality for) objective** values, values are what make a thing GOOD or BAD… how can atheism justify assigning objective universal values (like good, bad) to random actions? It simply can’t. Even if it could, where do the OBLIGATIONS come from? Why OUGHT we do good, and not bad? In atheism there is only IS, and so there can be no objective OUGHTS, there no objective ought* “giver.” So atheism has no way around Hume’s Guillotine. There is also absolutely no way to justify saying that an objective moral standard exists, where on earth would that come from? An objective moral standard that is immaterial and above humans which we are all subject to somehow? The idea of such a thing is absurd in atheism. Then you also have the problem of human dignity. Where do humans get dignity from in atheism? If humans are just animals, then what objectively gives us more dignity than dogs, ants, or bacteria? What is the trait that would actually give humans some type of moral worth above other animals that wasn’t totally arbitrary? There is none. Needless to say, after four years of trying to justify objective morality without God, I totally failed. Still, to say, “rape is wrong but that’s just my opinion” was absurd. I didn’t believe it. 4/12🪡
5
The next crucial part of my story happened one day when I realized I was being a total hypocrite in my epistemology. Epistemology is the theory of how we can KNOW things, and I believed that all knowledge comes from sense data. If I could see it, smell it, touch it, I believed in it. This is called “empiricism.” So I said “I don’t believe in God because I’ve never seen God. I don’t believe in Santa Clause as I’ve never seen Santa Clause. Show me Santa Clause and I’ll believe in Santa.” Well, one day I realized, “wait a second… I’m making arguments for why I don’t believe in God… but all arguments appeal to **logic**…. Why do I believe in the existence of logic? I’ve never seen logic, never smelt logic, never held it in my hand. Not only that but I didn’t believe logic was even made of matter. I was a materialist.* If everything that exists, exists as matter and energy, why did I believe in something that exists as neither matter… nor energy? Plus I had zero evidence for the existence of logic. This was a huge problem, I was being directly inconsistent in my epistemology. And not just with logic. Numbers… uniformity of nature… my “self” and consciousness, information, knowledge, truth… there are so many things we believe in that cannot be sensed or tested or proven to exist in any scientific way. 5/12🪡
6
At this point, I brought this subject up to a fellow atheist friend on discord. I asked him, “hey, why are we calling ourselves empiricists and skeptics when we are taking all this stuff over here (logic, truth, etc) totally for granted with zero evidence? He said, and this is true, “if you keep asking questions like this, you won’t be an atheist much longer.” It turned out he was right. 6/12🪡
7
As an atheist, I had been one BECAUSE I thought it was true. I thought God was made up, God was fiction. But now I realized I was being inconsistent in my beliefs. My reasons for rejecting belief in God should have also lead to the rejection of belief in logic, truth, numbers, my ability to reason, free will. Essentially, if I was going to be consistent** in my epistemology… I would have to give up all those things (truth logic etc) and basically die (how can anyone live without using logic, or induction)? Furthermore, I wouldn’t even have a good reason for giving this all up because I had given up logic. So to be consistent in my epistemology would mean to reject logic, which would be, illogical. In other words the argument to get rid of logic would itself be… assuming logic… which is a contradiction… so I couldn’t give up logic even if I wanted to because there’s NO GOOD reason to. Then I realized another even bigger problem, and this was with atheism itself. 7/12🪡
8
The problem deals with the nature of knowledge. Essentially the atheist in their worldview can’t justify having any knowledge… an all knowing mind is actually a required precondition for the possibility of knowledge and the atheist rejects this (they don’t believe in God), so the atheist is left ultimately saying “I know nothing.” But that’s a contradiction because all claims of knowledge OR ignorance are knowledge claims. So the atheist is actually making a knowledge claim about their lack of knowledge which amounts to… “I KNOW that I know nothing.” And this is a contradiction. 8/12🪡
9
So atheism leads to absurdity and contradiction, and therefore literally cannot be true. If atheism cannot be true, then there must be at least one God. When I realized all this I knew that there was a God. Not only this but God actually created justification for all these beliefs. If God existed, objective morality could exist, logic could exist, and truth, God was an all knowing being who could give me knowledge through revelation, and uniformity of nature made sense as it could be caused by God’s will to keep the world uniform so we could make plans and have stability. Everything clicked into place. 9/12🪡
10
When I realized God must exist, I knew if he did, he was good. If God was good, shouldn’t I serve him? It’s shameful to admit but I waited three entire months to get down on my knees and give my life to God (I wanted to sin more, and I had an enormous ego, frankly). When I finally did do it, I said, “God I know you exist, I know you’re good, and I want to give you my life and serve you.” When I got up from that prayer, everything was different. Suddenly the world seemed magical, my life had a purpose! I wasn’t just a speck floating in space anymore, I was a creature loved by an all powerful loving God. I had a stupid smile on my face as I walked to get food that night, looking up at the stars like I used to as a child, in wonder and amazement at God’s creation. 10/12🪡
11
Soon after that I heard the *gospel* of Jesus Christ, how I was a sinner (I had lied, cheated, lusted, stolen, you name it) and how I deserved to go to hell for my sins which I had committed against a perfect holy God. I learned how God loved me even though I was his enemy and how he sent his son to this terrible world where he lived as a man like me, but he lived a perfect sinless life, and then he died for my sins and the sins of the world in the worst way imaginable, all because of his love.. for us. He then conquered death and rose on the third day so that all who **believe in him as their savior** would not perish but also have everlasting life, with him in heaven. 11/12🪡
12
Suddenly the Gospel, which had NEVER made sense, made sense to me. I knew it was the truth, and I was a Christian. Since then God transformed my life. I no longer had any desire to smoke, drink, watch degenerate Hollywood films, be mean to people and upset them, and I don’t even watch porn anymore, which is an absolute miracle. God changed my life, he turned me from a bitter, proud, selfish jerk that no one liked, into someone that genuinely cares about people, and wants to do the right thing even when no one is looking. I’m not perfect and I never will be, but I love Jesus and I have peace, and real joy now, and I know where I’m going when I die. If you’re an atheist or unbeliever reading this, I want you to know I love you and I would love to talk to you about Jesus, anytime. Thank you for reading this thread, God bless. 12/12🪡🧵
Actions
What You Can Do
  • Export as PDF or Markdown
  • Batch Export to Notion
  • Bookmark & Highlight
  • Screenshot Tweet
Create Free Account

Includes 7-day Premium trial

Advertisement