Against The Rule of One A fundamental principle of many Neo-...

Yusuf@YusufTheist
4 views
May 04, 2025
~1 min read
Advertisement
1
Against The Rule of One
A fundamental principle of many Neo-Platonic and Emanationist philosophies is the Rule of One. This is the idea that The One, or the First Cause who is absolutely simple, can only cause or create one effect.
A fundamental principle of many Neo-Platonic and Emanationist philosophies is the Rule of One. This is the idea that The One, or the First Cause who is absolutely simple, can only cause or create one effect.
2
If the One could cause multiple effects, this would supposedly introduce multiplicity in it. Hence, it can only cause one effect and no other.
This principle has a devastating consequence: it entails that there would be no ultimate simple cause.
This principle has a devastating consequence: it entails that there would be no ultimate simple cause.
3
The reason is because if multiple ontological realities cannot derive or be grounded in one and the same ontological reality, then the multiple ontological realities in the material universe must derive or be grounded in the same amount of more fundamental ontological realities.
4
And those ontological realities would have to derive or be grounded in the same amount of more fundamental ontological realities again. And so on.
Such a series would never terminate at a single absolutely simple cause. Multiplicity would always reduce to multiplicity.
Such a series would never terminate at a single absolutely simple cause. Multiplicity would always reduce to multiplicity.
5
But, the foundation of these Neo-Platonic and emanationist ontologies is the One, who is the absolutely simple first principle.
Hence, there seems to be an inescapable internal inconsistency with such metaphysical systems.
Hence, there seems to be an inescapable internal inconsistency with such metaphysical systems.