@IbnHusayn02: Maybe if I respond to his low-...
@IbnHusayn02
4 views
Aug 25, 2025
1
Maybe if I respond to his low-level claims, then he will come out of occultation and show bravery. However, I highly doubt this happening, due him already running and blocking me.
Let us by the will of Allah SWT respond to claims of this Kafir son of Zurarah the filth.
Let us by the will of Allah SWT respond to claims of this Kafir son of Zurarah the filth.
2
His first claim is the Prophet ﷺ urinating while standing.
What is the issue exactly? It is permissible to urinate standing, especially in places of uneven surface, mud, rocks or any such thing that would hinder comfort. And many companions are reported to have done so-
What is the issue exactly? It is permissible to urinate standing, especially in places of uneven surface, mud, rocks or any such thing that would hinder comfort. And many companions are reported to have done so-
3
including ʿAlī, ʿUmar, Zayd ibn Thābit, Anas ibn Mālik and many others as mentioned by al-Nawawī in his Sharḥ of Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim.
Read below:
Read below:
4
The scholars have included many possibilities of why the Prophet ﷺ urinated while standing in that particular occasion, when he normally would be seated. It is mentioned in the same section in Sharḥ Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim by al-Nawawī. The third possibility seems to be the most likely
5
while all the given explanations are possible and valid.
Read below from al-Nawawī in his Sharḥ of Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim - He presents the different perspectives and views from the scholars.
Read below from al-Nawawī in his Sharḥ of Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim - He presents the different perspectives and views from the scholars.
6
Also, coming back to the point of urinate standing, especially in places of uneven surface, mud, rocks or any such thing that would hinder comfort.
This is supported by majority of scholars and the Prophet ﷺ himself is the criteria here.
Read below, ibn Qutaybah al-Dīnawarī
This is supported by majority of scholars and the Prophet ﷺ himself is the criteria here.
Read below, ibn Qutaybah al-Dīnawarī
7
The crux of the matter and the conclusion is that standing while urinating is permissible.
And most importantly….. His infallible imam allowed it 😉
And most importantly….. His infallible imam allowed it 😉
8
His second claim is that the Prophet ﷺ died after urinating. So what? What is the substance of your argument? What does such prove? Absolutely nothing.
since you don’t have an alternative sirah of the Prophet ﷺ and the fact that Twelver Shiism had not come out of the balls of-
since you don’t have an alternative sirah of the Prophet ﷺ and the fact that Twelver Shiism had not come out of the balls of-
9
of Hisham Ibn Hakam the kafir yet, you shut your mouth and listen when we tell you about the Prophet ﷺ. We tell you about him and you listen like good obedient slaves.
Not only the Sirah, but have to rely on us for reports on the Ahlul bayt.
Not only the Sirah, but have to rely on us for reports on the Ahlul bayt.
10
His third point: The Prophet ﷺ prayed while being in a state of major impurity.
I don’t know if this is deliberate deception or simply his inability to comprehend and read? I think it is the latter, because this individual clearly is on the lower end of the IQ scale.
I don’t know if this is deliberate deception or simply his inability to comprehend and read? I think it is the latter, because this individual clearly is on the lower end of the IQ scale.
11
Here is the report. Read it for yourselves brothers. He has derived from this text that the Prophet ﷺ prayed while in a state of major impurity.
The report mentions that the Prophet ﷺ would do ablution (like you do with prayer) before sleeping when he was Junub.
The report mentions that the Prophet ﷺ would do ablution (like you do with prayer) before sleeping when he was Junub.
