@alex_prompter: I tested Grok 3 — claimed to b...
@alex_prompter
41 views
Feb 20, 2025
1
I tested Grok 3 — claimed to be the "smartest AI model" — against ChatGPT o3-mini & DeepSeek R1 with critical prompts.
Grok 3 vs. DeepSeek R1 vs. ChatGPT o3-mini
The results will surprise you.
(Video demos included) 🧵👇
Grok 3 vs. DeepSeek R1 vs. ChatGPT o3-mini
The results will surprise you.
(Video demos included) 🧵👇
2
1/ Quantum entanglement
Prompt I used:
"Explain the concept of quantum entanglement and its implications for information transfer."
Prompt I used:
"Explain the concept of quantum entanglement and its implications for information transfer."
3
📌 Expected Answer:
- Particles remain correlated over distance.
- Cannot transmit information faster than light.
- Used in quantum cryptography, teleportation.
Results:
✅ DeepSeek R1: Best structured answer, explained Bell’s theorem, EPR paradox, and practical applications.
✅ Grok 3: Solid explanation but less depth than DeepSeek R1. Included Einstein’s "spooky action at a distance."
❌ ChatGPT o3-mini: Gave a basic overview but lacked technical depth.
🏆 Winner: DeepSeek R1
- Particles remain correlated over distance.
- Cannot transmit information faster than light.
- Used in quantum cryptography, teleportation.
Results:
✅ DeepSeek R1: Best structured answer, explained Bell’s theorem, EPR paradox, and practical applications.
✅ Grok 3: Solid explanation but less depth than DeepSeek R1. Included Einstein’s "spooky action at a distance."
❌ ChatGPT o3-mini: Gave a basic overview but lacked technical depth.
🏆 Winner: DeepSeek R1
4
2/ Renewable Energy Research (Past Month)
Prompt I used:
"Summarize the latest renewable energy research published in the past month."
Prompt I used:
"Summarize the latest renewable energy research published in the past month."
5
📌 Expected Answer:
- Identify major energy advancements in the last month.
- Cite sources with dates.
- Cover solar, wind, hydrogen, and policy updates.
Results:
✅ DeepSeek R1: Most comprehensive. Covered solar, wind, AI in energy forecasting, and battery tech with solid technical insights.
✅ Grok 3: Focused on hydrogen storage, solar on reservoirs, and policy changes but lacked broader coverage.
❌ ChatGPT o3-mini: Too vague, provided country-level summaries but lacked citations and specific studies.
🏆 Winner: DeepSeek R1
- Identify major energy advancements in the last month.
- Cite sources with dates.
- Cover solar, wind, hydrogen, and policy updates.
Results:
✅ DeepSeek R1: Most comprehensive. Covered solar, wind, AI in energy forecasting, and battery tech with solid technical insights.
✅ Grok 3: Focused on hydrogen storage, solar on reservoirs, and policy changes but lacked broader coverage.
❌ ChatGPT o3-mini: Too vague, provided country-level summaries but lacked citations and specific studies.
🏆 Winner: DeepSeek R1
6
3/ Universal Basic Income (UBI) Economic Impact
Prompt I used:
"Analyze the economic impacts of Universal Basic Income (UBI) in developed countries."
Prompt I used:
"Analyze the economic impacts of Universal Basic Income (UBI) in developed countries."
7
📌 Expected Answer:
- Cover effects on poverty, employment, inflation, government budgets.
- Mention real-world trials (e.g., Finland, Alaska).
- Balance positive & negative impacts.
Results:
✅ Grok 3: Best structured answer. Cited Finland’s trial, Alaska Permanent Fund, and analyzed taxation effects.
✅ DeepSeek R1: Detailed but dense. Good breakdown of pros/cons, but slightly over-explained.
❌ ChatGPT o3-mini: Superficial, no real-world trials or case studies.
🏆 Winner: Grok 3
- Cover effects on poverty, employment, inflation, government budgets.
- Mention real-world trials (e.g., Finland, Alaska).
- Balance positive & negative impacts.
Results:
✅ Grok 3: Best structured answer. Cited Finland’s trial, Alaska Permanent Fund, and analyzed taxation effects.
✅ DeepSeek R1: Detailed but dense. Good breakdown of pros/cons, but slightly over-explained.
❌ ChatGPT o3-mini: Superficial, no real-world trials or case studies.
🏆 Winner: Grok 3
8
4/ Physics Puzzle (Marble & Cup Test)
Prompt I used:
"Assume the laws of physics on Earth. A small marble is put into a normal cup and the cup is placed upside down on a table. Someone then takes the cup and puts it inside the microwave. Where is the ball now? Explain your reasoning step by step."
Prompt I used:
"Assume the laws of physics on Earth. A small marble is put into a normal cup and the cup is placed upside down on a table. Someone then takes the cup and puts it inside the microwave. Where is the ball now? Explain your reasoning step by step."
9
📌 Expected Answer:
- The marble falls out of the cup when it’s lifted.
- The marble remains on the table, not in the microwave.
Results:
✅ DeepSeek R1: Thought the longest but nailed the physics, explaining gravity and friction correctly.
✅ Grok 3: Solid reasoning but overcomplicated the explanation with excessive detail.
❌ ChatGPT o3-mini: Incorrect. Claimed the marble stays in the cup despite gravity.
🏆 Winner: DeepSeek R1
- The marble falls out of the cup when it’s lifted.
- The marble remains on the table, not in the microwave.
Results:
✅ DeepSeek R1: Thought the longest but nailed the physics, explaining gravity and friction correctly.
✅ Grok 3: Solid reasoning but overcomplicated the explanation with excessive detail.
❌ ChatGPT o3-mini: Incorrect. Claimed the marble stays in the cup despite gravity.
🏆 Winner: DeepSeek R1
10
5/ Global Temperature Trends (Last 100 Years)
Prompt I used:
"Analyze global temperature changes over the past century and summarize key trends."
Prompt I used:
"Analyze global temperature changes over the past century and summarize key trends."
11
📌 Expected Answer:
- ~1.5°C warming since 1925.
- Clear acceleration post-1970.
- Cooling period 1940–1970 due to aerosols.
Results:
✅ Grok 3: Best structured answer. Cited NASA, IPCC, NOAA, provided real anomaly data, historical context, and a timeline.
✅ DeepSeek R1: Strong details but lacked citations. Good analysis of regional variations & Arctic amplification.
❌ ChatGPT o3-mini: Basic overview with no data or citations.
🏆 Winner: Grok 3
- ~1.5°C warming since 1925.
- Clear acceleration post-1970.
- Cooling period 1940–1970 due to aerosols.
Results:
✅ Grok 3: Best structured answer. Cited NASA, IPCC, NOAA, provided real anomaly data, historical context, and a timeline.
✅ DeepSeek R1: Strong details but lacked citations. Good analysis of regional variations & Arctic amplification.
❌ ChatGPT o3-mini: Basic overview with no data or citations.
🏆 Winner: Grok 3
12
🎯 Final Scoreboard
🏆 DeepSeek R1: 3 Wins
🏆 Grok 3: 2 Wins
❌ ChatGPT o3-mini: 0 Wins
DeepSeek R1 is the overall winner, but Grok 3 dominated in citation-based research.
🏆 DeepSeek R1: 3 Wins
🏆 Grok 3: 2 Wins
❌ ChatGPT o3-mini: 0 Wins
DeepSeek R1 is the overall winner, but Grok 3 dominated in citation-based research.
13
That's a wrap!
Which AI do YOU trust more? 🤖
If you found this useful:
📧 Subscribe to my FREE newsletter: godofprompt.ai/subscribe
🔄 RT & Follow for more AI breakdowns!
Which AI do YOU trust more? 🤖
If you found this useful:
📧 Subscribe to my FREE newsletter: godofprompt.ai/subscribe
🔄 RT & Follow for more AI breakdowns!
View Tweet